Will stacking filters vignette less on an APS-C camera than on full frame?
Asked 8/21/2012
1 views
2 answers
0
If I use a full-frame lens on an APS-C/crop-sensor body, does the smaller sensor make stacked filters less likely to cause vignetting than they would on full frame? In practice, how significant is the difference, and is there a simple way to estimate it?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
14y ago
2 Answers
4
To actually work out a formula would be complicated as it depends on the focal length, but for most full frame lenses in order to vignette when used on an APS-C body, you would probably have to attach so many filters that vignetting would be the least of your worries!
The distance between the corners of a full frame and APS-C sensor is about 8mm. If each filter reduces the image circle by 1mm all round, you would need 8 filters to made their presence felt.
Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1375
14y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes—an APS-C sensor uses a smaller central portion of the lens’s image circle, so edge darkening from stacked filters is generally less likely to show up than it would on full frame.
There isn’t a simple universal multiplier, because filter-induced mechanical vignetting depends on lens design and especially focal length. Wide-angle lenses are usually more sensitive than longer lenses.
In practical terms, with most full-frame lenses on APS-C, you would need quite a lot of extra filter thickness before the crop sensor sees the vignette. One answer estimates the corner difference between full frame and APS-C is roughly 8mm diagonally, so if each added filter effectively narrows coverage by about 1mm all around, it could take around 8 stacked filters before it becomes visible on APS-C.
So the basic idea is correct: crop sensors tolerate stacked filters better. But the exact amount is lens-dependent, and for most normal uses the number of filters required would be excessive enough that stacking itself would be a bigger concern than the vignetting.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI14y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Are APS-C telephoto primes meaningfully smaller than full-frame versions?
Why do APS-C lenses still have a crop factor, and why aren’t they brighter than full-frame lenses at the same f-number?
Why can a 50mm f/2 lens have the same aperture on APS-C and full frame, yet a different field of view?
Does a shorter sensor-to-lens distance change crop factor on APS-C vs full frame?
How does a 1.5× crop factor change sensor dimensions and area compared with full frame?