Does a shorter sensor-to-lens distance change crop factor on APS-C vs full frame?
Asked 10/28/2022
5 views
2 answers
0
My APS-C camera has about a 1.6x crop factor compared with full frame. But on some mirrorless/CSC cameras the sensor sits closer to the lens than on a DSLR. If the sensor is closer to the lens, wouldn’t the projected image be smaller too, and partly cancel out the crop from the smaller sensor? Or is crop factor determined only by sensor size?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
3y ago
2 Answers
2
A lens is designed to project an image circle of a certain size in order to cover an image area (sensor) of a certain size... and for that image circle to be in focus at that distance (flange distance). If you arbitrarily change the distance you change the crop factor (size relative to the image circle) and adversely affect the lens' ability to focus at all distances.
What you are describing is more commonly known as "bellows factor." If you attach a lens to a bellows, when you move the lens father away from the image area/sensor the projected image circle spreads out more over the increased distance (although the additional area/size created may be masked out). This causes an increase in the effective magnification (increased crop factor); and simultaneously causes a reduction in the light density at the image plane (resulting in a smaller effective aperture). It also prevents the lens from focusing at longer distances (incorrect/long flange distance).
And the opposite is also true... less distance = less projected image spread, less magnification/crop factor, greater light density, and an inability to focus as close.
Originally by user70370. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user70370
3y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
No. Crop factor is determined by sensor size relative to the lens’s image circle and resulting angle of view, not by mirrorless cameras having a shorter flange distance.
A lens is designed to form a focused image at a specific flange focal distance for its mount. If you change that distance arbitrarily, the lens will no longer focus properly as intended. So a shorter sensor-to-lens distance does not “shrink” the image in a way that cancels crop; the lens and camera are designed together so the image is formed correctly at that distance.
What changes field of view between APS-C and full frame is that the smaller sensor records a smaller central portion of the same image circle, which is why it appears cropped.
Moving a lens farther from the sensor with extension tubes or bellows is a different case: that increases magnification and reduces light, but it is not how normal crop factor works.
So: for equivalent lens designs on their intended mounts, crop factor comes from sensor size, while flange distance mainly affects lens design and adaptation possibilities.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI3y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Does Nikon’s 1.5x APS-C crop factor mean its sensor is meaningfully closer to full frame than Canon’s 1.6x?
Does a crop sensor change lens distortion or portrait perspective?
Why do APS-C lenses still have a crop factor, and why aren’t they brighter than full-frame lenses at the same f-number?
How does a 1.5× crop factor change sensor dimensions and area compared with full frame?
Does an APS-C camera give more reach with a full-frame 100-400mm lens?