Why do smooth sky gradients show pale arcs or bands in my photos?
Asked 7/25/2019
4 views
2 answers
0
I shot some images on a Sony A7 II and noticed faint pale/white arcs in areas of clear blue sky. The files were captured in RAW, but the artifacts are visible in the image I’m viewing/exporting. What causes these arcs in smooth gradients, and is this a RAW/JPEG issue?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
6y ago
2 Answers
3
This is known as "banding". This happens when you have uniform color gradients and the quantization by the camera (because JPEG is only 8bits/channel) transforms them into uniform areas. Along the edge of these areas the value "jumps" and our eyes are quite sensitive to this. This can be checked with the histogram, which assumes a hair comb shape (the spikes are the values in the areas):
Ironically, this is less visible if there is noise, so bad cameras are pretty much immune from this. If you have the raw image this can be remediated (possibly by adding some noise...). "Spread noise" (where pixels are randomly swapped) is another way to mitigate this.
Originally by user75947. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user75947
6y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Those arcs are most likely banding (also called posterization) in a smooth gradient like blue sky. It happens when subtle tonal transitions get reduced into larger steps, so instead of a continuous gradient you see visible bands or arcs where the tone “jumps.”
This is especially common in JPEG, because JPEG is typically 8-bit per channel and also uses compression that throws away subtle image information. RAW files usually preserve more tonal data, so the issue is often introduced during previewing, editing, or exporting to JPEG rather than by the sensor itself.
A histogram can reveal this: banding often produces a comb-like pattern instead of a smooth distribution.
To reduce it:
- edit from the RAW file when possible
- avoid heavy adjustments to smooth gradients
- export to higher-bit formats when available during editing
- add a tiny amount of noise/dither/grain if needed, which can make banding less visible
So your friend’s explanation isn’t quite right: JPEG isn’t “defaulting to white,” but limited bit depth/compression can make smooth color transitions break into visible bands.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI6y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why do I see blocky sky gradients in Lightroom, even from RAW files?
Why do I see color banding in the sky after switching from JPEG to RAW in Lightroom?
Why does sky darkening in Photoshop cause banding, and how can I avoid it?
What causes streaks or brush-mark artifacts in cyanotype highlights?
Why are my star trails jagged instead of smooth?
