Why are my star trails jagged instead of smooth?

Asked 6/25/2020

6 views

2 answers

0

I shot a 1+ hour star-trail sequence on a tripod with a Sony A7R IV and 16-35mm lens at 16mm, ISO 640, f/3.5, using 30-second exposures in continuous mode with a remote release. Focus was manual and conditions were mostly clear near the ocean. When I stacked the images, the star trails looked uneven and bumpy instead of smooth arcs. What usually causes this, how can I avoid it next time, and is there any way to improve it in post?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

6y ago

2 Answers

9

Looks to me like you might have forgotten to turn off image stabilisation in camera and/or lens.

Image stabilisation uses acceleration sensors to estimate movement/shake of the camera/lens and then moves optical elements or the sensor to compensate. On a tripod, this does more harm than benefit since errors in the estimated movement accumulate and cause the compensation to drift. When the compensation drifts out of its capture range, the stabilisation may reset it to a neutral position.

Some cameras may autodetect when they are on a tripod or similar and switch off image stabilisation on their own, but that's not a given. And particularly with multiple exposures, you don't get a guarantee that each shot will start at the same compensation position even when the camera then does not change it while exposing. Switching stabilisation off fixes sensor and compensation lens elements in place.

Originally by user92750. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user92750

6y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

The most likely cause is image stabilization being left on while the camera was on a tripod. IBIS/lens stabilization can drift during long tripod-mounted sequences, then recenter, which creates the jagged or stepped star trails you’re seeing.

Other possible contributors are slight camera movement (tripod vibration, wind, something touching the setup) and atmospheric turbulence, especially near the ocean where air movement can be stronger.

To prevent it next time:

  • Turn off in-body and lens stabilization when shooting star trails on a tripod.
  • Make sure the tripod is very stable and protected from wind or accidental bumps.
  • Keep using a remote release and avoid touching the camera.
  • If possible, choose calmer conditions.

In post, there’s no perfect fix if the frames themselves are misaligned by stabilization drift. You can sometimes improve the result by aligning individual frames before stacking, but if the shift varies within or between exposures, the artifacts may remain. The best solution is to reshoot with stabilization off and a stable setup.

UniqueBot

AI

6y ago

Your Answer