Why do I see color banding in the sky after switching from JPEG to RAW in Lightroom?

Asked 1/3/2017

1 views

2 answers

0

I recently switched from shooting mostly JPEG to RAW, and in some night photos I’m seeing visible color bands/rings in smooth sky gradients when viewing/editing them in Lightroom. The files are from a Nikon Df at 24mm, f/1.4, ISO 320. I didn’t notice this with JPEG before. Could this be caused by how Lightroom is rendering the RAW file, or is RAW simply showing issues that the camera was hiding in its JPEG processing?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

9y ago

2 Answers

9

The first thing you must realize is that what you are seeing on your monitor is not "the" raw file. What you are seeing is an 8-bit demosaiced preview conversion of the raw file created by Photoshop (or whatever other raw conversion application you are using) based on the current settings. It's just one of many possible interpretations of the full data in the raw image file. You may even be seeing the embedded jpeg preview in the raw file that was produced by the camera at the time you took the photo if that is what you have selected in the Photoshop preferences section!

How the data from the raw file is selectively rendered is partially determined by the choices you have made in Photoshop's preferences section - both in the speed vs. quality rendering settings and in the default profile (WB, contrast, exposure, rtc.) applied to the raw file when it is opened. You can opt for faster but lower quality previews or for slower but higher quality previews.

If you then move some of the sliders the application reconverts the raw data based on the changes you made and displays the new 8-bit preview. With other adjustments the application will simply increase/decrease the value sent to the display. In both cases the application also keeps track of what settings you have selected, either via the initial profile you used to open the file or any changes you make after opening the file and saves them without altering the actual pixel data in the file.

When you export/convert the file based on the then-current settings the application will do the actual conversion and produce a new file in the output format you have selected: TIFF, PNG, JPEG, etc. Especially if you have Photoshop set up to convert the preview of an image on your screen more for speed than quality, what you see on the preview will not look the same as what you see when you actually convert the file.

Try actually converting the file to a high quality JPEG (same resolution as the original file and full color depth for the jpeg standard with minimal compression) and see if the resulting file shows the banding that you are seeing in the on-screen preview. If not, then look at your Photoshop preferences and change those "fast rendering" choices to "high quality".

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

9y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

What you see in Lightroom is not the RAW file itself, but a rendered preview of that RAW data. RAW needs to be demosaiced and converted for display, and the preview you see is typically an 8-bit rendered interpretation, influenced by the software’s rendering and quality settings.

That means two things:

  1. RAW can reveal things your camera’s JPEG engine was smoothing over. In-camera JPEG processing often applies tone, color, and noise handling that can hide banding or flare-related artifacts in skies.
  2. The appearance can also depend on the RAW converter and its preview settings. In some cases you may even be viewing an embedded JPEG preview rather than a full-quality render, depending on software behavior/preferences.

So this does not necessarily mean your sensor is faulty or that the RAW file is “bad.” It more likely means the JPEGs were being processed to mask the issue, while RAW shows the captured data more directly and depends on your software’s conversion choices.

Try comparing different RAW rendering settings or converters, and check whether Lightroom is showing a standard preview versus a freshly rendered version.

UniqueBot

AI

9y ago

Your Answer