Why do many camera flashes use AA batteries instead of proprietary lithium packs?

Asked 5/13/2014

4 views

2 answers

0

Camera bodies often use proprietary rechargeable lithium-ion batteries, while many speedlights have traditionally run on AA cells. If proprietary lithium packs can deliver compact design and strong current for cameras, why have flashes so often used AAs instead? What design or user-experience tradeoffs explain the difference, and is flash performance actually better with lithium packs?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

11

The ergonomics and weight balance of a camera are more important than that of a flash. By incorporating a proprietary battery into the camera design the manufacturer has more flexibility on its size, shape and position in the camera. This can reduce the size of the battery compartment, simplify the access door and battery contacts, and means that more power can be stored in a tighter space. This is particularly important in compact cameras. I don't think it's just about the power output and capacity of the batteries. I imagine a more holistic approach to the design of the battery and how it integrates with the camera is involved.

Also, considering that the voltage options for off-the-shelf batteries tend to be nominally 1.5V per cell with the exception of a PP9 (9V), more than one cell would be required to deliver sufficient current to operate the mirror, shutter and lens effectively. In an SLR I expect you would need at least 4 or 6 AA batteries to achieve that, adding considerable bulk to the camera and your camera bag (imagine the spares). :)

Finally, let's not forget that the flash contains a capacitor because of the high voltages involved and that power is transferred from the battery to the capacitor prior to firing -- in this respect, the battery isn't directly driving the flash, the capacitor is, so the battery specifications are less important in the design.

Originally by user28030. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user28030

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

The main reasons are design flexibility and user convenience.

For cameras, a proprietary battery lets the maker optimize size, shape, placement, contacts, and capacity as part of the body design. That matters a lot for ergonomics, compactness, and fitting the required voltage and power into a tight space.

For flashes, the tradeoff is different. Speedlights often drain batteries much faster and need replacements more often, especially during heavy use. AA cells are cheap, common, and easy to replace anywhere, which is a big practical advantage for a flash. Rechargeable AAs also keep costs and logistics simple for many users.

That said, proprietary lithium flash packs can offer real performance benefits, including faster and more consistent recycle times as the battery discharges. Some flashes and external battery packs do use lithium systems for exactly that reason.

So it’s not that AAs are always technically better; rather, flashes have often prioritized easy battery replacement and broad availability, while cameras prioritize integrated design and packaging efficiency. Newer lithium-powered flashes show that when performance is the priority, proprietary packs can be a better solution.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer