Why do many cameras use proprietary battery packs instead of standard AA batteries?

Asked 5/12/2014

3 views

2 answers

0

My camera uses a proprietary rechargeable battery pack, while AA rechargeables are cheaper, widely available, and have been used in cameras before. What are the practical reasons manufacturers choose custom battery packs instead of standard AAs? Are the main reasons technical, such as performance, size, and battery communication, or is it mostly about manufacturer profit?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

17

Although only the manufacturers themselves know for sure and there could be different reasons from one manufacturer to the next there are two obvious possibilities that receive most of the attention from the users of cameras and their proprietary batteries.

Profit. Limiting the amount of competition in the marketplace by not using standard, off the shelf batteries means the camera manufacturers can charge more for the proprietary batteries that fit their cameras. Even though third party batteries are usually available, the market tends to look down on them more than they would if something with the name Energizer or Ray-O-Vac was printed on the side. In some cases third party batteries are superior to the OEM batteries, but the lack of brand name recognition scares many buyers away.

Increased capability. Many cameras can communicate with the proprietary batteries. This allows them to identify each unique battery and tell the camera such things as how many shots since the battery was at 100%, the power level of each battery in your collection when it was last inside the camera, the current charge state of each battery in the camera, and the recharge performance of each battery. Beyond communicating with the camera, different chemistry allows different batteries to discharge at different rates and with varying amounts of endurance. A proprietary design can be designed to meet the optimal needs of the camera design in a way than a standardized off the shelf battery may not.

In reality the reason manufacturers use proprietary batteries is probably some of both of the above.

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

It’s a mix of engineering and business.

The main technical reason is form factor and power delivery. Custom lithium-ion packs can be shaped to fit the camera body efficiently, helping keep cameras smaller and allowing more capacity in the available space. They also tend to provide power in a way that better supports camera demands such as motor drive and other high-load functions. Some cameras that accept AAs show reduced performance when using them.

Another advantage is integration: proprietary packs can include electronics that let the camera report battery identity, condition, and other status information that loose AAs cannot provide.

There’s also a safety/regulatory angle. Rechargeable lithium cells need proper protection and charging control, so a purpose-built pack makes that easier to manage.

Profit is also a likely factor. A custom battery creates a captive accessory market, and many users prefer OEM packs over third-party options.

So the answer is not just “profit” or just “lithium is better.” Proprietary packs mainly offer packaging, integration, and performance advantages, while also giving manufacturers commercial benefits.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer