Why do DSLR battery grips usually use proprietary batteries instead of AA cells, and are there D3100 options?
Asked 5/30/2012
2 views
2 answers
0
I use a Nikon D3100 and noticed most battery grips take the same EN-EL14-type battery as the camera rather than standard cells like AA. I expected more grips to accept common battery sizes, but that seems rare. Is there a technical reason camera makers favor proprietary lithium-ion packs over AA/C/D batteries in cameras and grips? Also, if I want longer runtime on a D3100, is using a third-party grip with extra EN-EL14 batteries the practical approach?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
14y ago
2 Answers
6
Consider this half an answer or an answer to half your question :)
Most cameras on the market use custom batteries. This allows the camera manufacturer to provide a precise and reliable experience for the user. The downside is increased cost and inconvenience since options are limited.
AA batteries are great and Pentax still makes DSLRs that use AAs and can reach battery life above the majority of similar entry-level models. However the latest models, both the K-r and the soon-to-be-available K-30 support BOTH types of batteries. The reason is there was a lot of complaint with people getting very poor performance from AAs, far from the numbers provided by Pentax. With Lithium AAs on a K-r, you can get over 1500 shots!
The real problem is that most people who do not pay for proprietary batteries do not even pay for quality AA batteries! A good set of 4 AAs costs about $15-20 USD, depending on where you live. PowerEx and top-of-the-line Energizer or Sanyo as well as Imedion and Sanyo Eneloops fall in that category. The last two are less powerful but low-self-discharge so keep 90% of the power after 1 year without use while the first two empty themselves in 1-2 months. If your batteries are Alkaline, have a cat on them or say GP, consider them garbage.
Honestly I really like AAs and I was annoyed when I upgraded to a camera with proprietary battery particularly since I have been away from electricity for weeks at a time and a Solar AA charger purchased for about $25 served me well. For Li-Ion batteries a solar charger is not attractive because I would need one for each type of proprietary battery.
There are battery grips for other cameras which support AAs but I have not seen one for the D3100 other than the link you provided.
PS: I know how poor AA performance has been for those who skimped because I got hundreds of messages from people wondering why they got such low battery-life.
Originally by user1620. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1620
14y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes—there’s a good technical reason. DSLR makers generally use proprietary lithium-ion packs because they provide more consistent voltage and current, good performance across most of the charge, long service life, and reliable operation in varied conditions. Standard cells, especially AA rechargeables, can work but often have less consistent voltage toward the end of their charge and may deliver poorer real-world performance.
That’s why many battery grips are designed to hold one or two of the camera’s normal battery packs rather than AA/C/D cells: it keeps power delivery predictable for the camera.
AA-based solutions do exist in some camera systems, but they’re less common. If your goal is simply longer shooting time on a Nikon D3100, the practical route is usually a third-party grip plus additional EN-EL14-compatible batteries. Third-party batteries are commonly available and cheaper than OEM packs, though quality can vary. In short: proprietary Li-ion is favored mainly for performance and reliability, and for the D3100, a grip using extra camera batteries is the most typical solution.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI14y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why do many camera flashes use AA batteries instead of proprietary lithium packs?
Which battery types work best for cameras and flashes in very cold, high-altitude conditions?
Is a battery grip a good backup power option for a Canon 50D?
Can a worn-out DSLR lithium-ion battery be revived, and how should old batteries be recycled?
What AA batteries work best in a DSLR battery grip?