What lens characteristics make flare look attractive or harsh?
Asked 8/28/2013
3 views
2 answers
0
Some lenses produce harsh, low-contrast flare, while others create flare patterns people find pleasing or cinematic. What optical characteristics affect the look of lens flare, and why do different lenses render it differently?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
9
A Flair for flare.
Flare reduces the contrast of the image captured. It can affect the image overall or selectively. I'm going to make a great leap of faith and guess that you are after selective flare such as a round or symmetrical shape that plays across the image.
Your concept of what is beautiful and desirable versus undesirable is personal and will vary from person to person. Ironically, some lens designers lose sleep trying to eliminate flare. Flare would ruin any print by Ansel Adams, for an example. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
That said,
Flare is non-imaging illumination. It's increased with irregular contamination of the lens surface with objects of various size such as tiny pieces of dust. With some care and experimentation, you can place material on the surface of the glass itself. (You can be as carefree with this technique as your budget allows. You may just have to discard an expensive experiment, though. Yipes!)
An alternative is to shine a pattern of light directly onto the face of the glass from just outside the lens field of view. The variation of the source of flare from the image illumination will be enhanced against a dark image background.
Things in front of the lens that are not in focus can give the effect of flare, too. Wisps of hair or gossamer net, web, or lace will also appear as a kind of flare since it, too, reduces the overall image contrast.
Sometimes, flare is a term used to describe an effect caused by the internal reflections of the lens elements themselves. This effect is created by software in some science fiction films as we follow our heroes as they fly by bright objects in the heavens. They appear as aligned and often overlapping disks and circles of light that show against the darknesss of outer space. In this case, it is software that mimics the real effect.
The biggest contributing factor to lens flare is the ability of optical glass to bend or bounce light depending on the angle of the light ray hitting the surface of the glass. Shooting obliquely or directly into light sources can give unexpected pictorial results.
Some creative souls strive to create internal reflections, against the express desires of lens designers who want maximum image definition, with bits of reflective foil placed behind the lens mount and offset from the image cone. These are placed to reflect light back into the lens body to create image flare. With some practice it can be creatively controlled.
Putting stuff into your camera is not recommended for those with a limited budget. I'd also frown on anyone borrowing my equipment for their experiments without my permission. (But, I'd like to see your experiment tho'.)
Lens flare can be put into a lens on purpose by altering or removing what lens designers do to reduce it.
Flare is affected by the following characteristics, among others…
Anti-reflective lens coatings, the number, position, and type of light baffles within the lens barrel, the age and condition of the matte black anti-reflective paint within the lens body, the presence or lack of edge coating on each of the elements, the use of different optical adhesives for compound lenses, the lens formula, the lens glass, the scratch and dig specifications for the lens surface polishing, mechanical placement and alignment of one or more of the lens element, the presence or lack of contamination in the glass itself, what portion of the lens is active, etc. The number of flare-producing images formed by a lens system equals N(N-1)/2 where N represents the number of glass-air surfaces.
Light rays that are off axis and parallel to the lens axis create stronger flare than rays striking at a shallow angle cross-axis (orthogonal). Internal reflections are at a maximum when the incident light is within the field of view.
Rainbows, aka transverse colour aberration, are the result of the inability of R, G, & B not having the same degree of refraction when dispersed from a white ray off the lens axis. Those tend to come from reflection from the lens edges much as a dispersion prism breaks white into component wavelengths. We edgecoat lenses now to minimize this. We could use a bigger glass and keep the rays near the centre; but, that extra glass is not necessary, now that we know of the workaround.
IMPORTANT DETAIL: In order to create flare, it is necessary for some strong source of light to strike the objective surface of your lens. If no light source strikes your lens, the flare produced will not be strong enough to be seen clearly as flare in your image. That's why you must aim your lens toward a source or sources for the effect to be visible against a dark background. The lighting is an issue; but, not a lens issue. There's flare in every shot no matter how you shoot it; but, it is beyond your ability to see it most of the time.
Originally by user21789. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user21789
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Lens flare is stray, non-image-forming light caused when a very bright source hits the lens at an angle and reflects between lens surfaces instead of being properly refracted. The source may be in the frame or just outside it.
What makes flare look “good” or “bad” depends partly on taste, but the lens design matters. Key factors mentioned in the answers are:
- Coatings and glass treatment: These strongly affect how much light is reflected internally and the color/character of flare.
- Number and arrangement of lens elements/surfaces: Each air-glass surface can create reflections, so different optical formulas produce different flare shapes and intensity.
- Angle and position of the light source: Off-axis bright light is a common cause of visible flare.
- Surface contamination: Dust, haze, smudges, or added material can increase non-imaging light and reduce contrast.
In general, “beautiful” flare is usually selective and structured, while “ugly” flare is broad veiling glare that washes out the whole image. Some cine lenses are even designed or chosen for more distinctive flare rendering, while many still-photo lenses are optimized to suppress it.
Also note that some rainbow/checkerboard artifacts near bright lights can come from the sensor, not the lens.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
What causes lens flare, and do some lenses flare more than others?
How can I create a controlled sunstar or artistic lens flare in a landscape photo?
Can a lens have "too much contrast," especially for portraits?
Why do mirror lenses often have lower contrast and sharpness than refracting lenses?
How can I reduce lens flare when shooting toward the sun?