Does a shutter need to match the front lens element diameter?
Asked 4/18/2021
6 views
2 answers
0
I'm building a camera with a lens that has a very large front element (about 70mm diameter). I first assumed I would need a shutter of the same size, but now I'm wondering whether a smaller shutter could work if it is placed behind the lens.
Does the shutter/aperture need to be as large as the front element, or does it only need to be large enough not to block the light path to the image plane? In other words, if I use a smaller shutter behind the lens, will it change the effective aperture or cause vignetting? Also, what kinds of shutters are typically used for this sort of custom build?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
5y ago
2 Answers
5
I am assuming that if I use a shutter of a smaller diameter than the lens, the properties of the lens will change (for example, it will become less fast), because of the smaller aperture ring behind it?
That is not necessarily the case. The physical size of the aperture is (almost?) never the same size as the objective lens element; because its physical size is not what matters. What matters is whether the aperture obstructs the path that the light must follow while being focused at the image plane. That is the aperture's apparent/effective size as seen/magnified by the objective element (which is called the entrance pupil).
I.e. the aperture is (almost?) always a physical restriction; but what actually matters is if it is an optical restriction or not.
If the aperture diameter appears to be the same size as the objective element (due to the magnification of it), there will be no optical restriction to the light travel, and the lens's f-ratio/maximum aperture will be determined by the diameter of the objective element itself (it cannot be any larger). And if the aperture appears smaller than the objective element, then the lens's f-ratio will be determined by its apparent diameter because it is smaller and it is an optical restriction.
Originally by user70370. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user70370
5y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
No—the shutter does not need to match the diameter of the front lens element. What matters is whether the shutter opening is large enough, in its position in the optical path, to avoid clipping the light cone that reaches the image plane.
A smaller shutter behind the lens may be fine if its effective opening does not become the limiting aperture. If it does limit the light path, then it can reduce the effective aperture and/or cause vignetting. In lens terms, the important concept is the entrance pupil, not the raw front-element size.
Also, shutter size is more closely related to the image circle/sensor or film format than to the front glass size. Many lenses have front elements much larger than the opening needed farther back in the system.
For custom large-lens builds, alternatives mentioned include simple front-of-lens shutters such as a lens cap or hat, Packard-style pneumatic shutters, or DIY rotating/slit/knife shutters. Large formats may require larger shutter solutions, but you generally do not need a 70mm shutter just because the front element is 70mm.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI5y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why is a lens front element often larger than focal length ÷ f-number?
How can I measure the actual working aperture of a lens when taking a photo?
What is the difference between physical aperture and effective aperture in a lens?
What determines the size of a lens’s front element?
Can a thin camera body use a very large front lens element?