What determines the size of a lens’s front element?

Asked 11/22/2011

3 views

2 answers

0

Looking across different Nikon lenses, the front glass size seems inconsistent. Some fast or professional lenses have very large front elements, but others with similar focal lengths or good image quality do not. For example, some wide zooms and telephotos have huge front glass, while lenses like a 50mm f/1.8 or 105mm macro have much smaller front elements. What optical or design factors determine how large the front element needs to be? Is it mainly focal length, maximum aperture, sensor format, lens type, or something else?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

7

Generally speaking, a larger front element is necessary to achieve a wider maximum aperture. More specifically, a larger front element helps achieve the necessary "entrance pupil" diameter required for a given lens, provides the necessary primary light-gathering power of a lens, and helps achieve the necessary angle of view of the lens. (The entrance pupil is the diameter of the physical aperture as viewed through the front of the lens.)

The physical diameter of a lens generally must increase as the maximum aperture increases, and once you pass f/2.8, each additional stop greatly increases the physical size of the lens. Additionally, once you pass f/2.8, each additional stop requires a considerably greater amount of light, and larger front lens elements are a key factor in gathering that additional light.

For ultra-wide angle lenses, such as the 14mm f/2.8, a larger lens element is often necessary to assist in capturing light rays from a wide enough angle of incidence, more so than for achieving a wide aperture (14/2.8 = 5mm physical aperture, quite small.)

For wider-aperture telephoto lenses, the physical aperture tends to be much larger, which tends to dictate the size of the front lens element more than the necessity of gathering wide-angle incident light rays. The 70-200mm f/2.8 lenses have a physical aperture of 71.4mm, some 14 times larger than the 14mm f/2.8 lens.

Lenses like the 70-300f/4.5-5.6 and 24-120 f/3.5-5.6 have much smaller maximum apertures for their focal lengths. 300/5.6 = 53mm, some 1.5 times smaller for 100mm greater focal length. A 300mm f/2.8 lens would require a 107mm aperture, which is twice as large as a 300 f/5.6, and would require a much larger front lens element to gather enough light to accommodate such a large aperture. The 80-400mm again has a fairly small maximum aperture at its longest focal length...400/5.6 is 71.4mm again, vs. 100mm for the 200/2 and 107mm for the 300/2.8. The 80-400mm lens has a larger front element than say the 14/2.8 or even a 50/1.4 due to the physical size of its aperture...which even at f/5.6 is considerably larger than any wide angle lens. A 50mm f/1.0 lens would have a physical aperture of 50mm, which over 20mm smaller than the 71.4mm of a 400/5.6 lens.

Originally by user124. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user124

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Front element size is mostly driven by optical design, especially the required entrance pupil for a given focal length and maximum aperture.

In general:

  • Faster maximum apertures need larger elements. For the same focal length, an f/1.4 lens usually needs a larger front element than an f/1.8 version.
  • Full-frame lenses often need larger elements than crop-sensor lenses because they must cover a larger image circle.
  • Very wide-angle lenses may need large, strongly curved front elements to achieve the required angle of view.
  • Long fast telephotos also need large front elements because a long focal length combined with a wide aperture demands a large entrance pupil.

So there isn’t a simple one-to-one relationship with image quality, focal length alone, or zoom range alone. Two lenses with the same focal length can have very different front element sizes if their maximum apertures or optical formulas differ.

Also, the visible front glass is not the aperture itself—the key quantity is the entrance pupil, which is the aperture as seen through the front of the lens. Makers may also standardize some filter sizes across lens lines, so filter diameter is only a rough clue, not a strict rule.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer