Will a Dandelion chip enable focus confirmation on a Nikon D5200 with manual-focus lenses?
Asked 9/15/2017
2 views
2 answers
0
I use a Nikon D5200, which has no in-body autofocus motor. With an older Nikon 28-80mm AF lens, the camera switches to manual focus because the lens needs a body motor. I also use several manual-focus lenses and am considering a Dandelion chip so I can get focus confirmation.
Will a Dandelion chip provide focus confirmation on a D5200 with manual-focus lenses, even though the camera cannot autofocus screw-drive AF lenses?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
8y ago
2 Answers
2
The 28-80 has everything your D5200 needs to function in manual mode, including focus confirmation. AF-S or AF-I are required for the body to focus the lens, but the parts that determine whether or not the image is in focus don't need it.
Lenses like that one tend to have lightweight, low-drag mechanicals that make it easy for the in-body focus motor to focus rapidly and precisely. Lenses built for manual-focus only tend to have some drag that makes precise focusing by hand much easier.
When you're trying to focus a low-drag lens by hand, it's very easy to pass the very-small point where the AF system thinks the image is in focus, making it look like you're not getting confirmation at all. There's a custom setting (a4 on the D5200, a-something-else on other Nikon bodies) that will switch the exposure meter in the viewfinder to a rangefinder that indicates of how close to in focus you are and which direction.
Adding a Dandelion chip to your other lenses will turn them into CPU lenses that give the body enough information to enable in-camera metering. It won't do anything focus-related.
Originally by user6508. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user6508
8y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes. Focus confirmation and autofocus are separate things.
On the D5200, AF-S or AF-I lenses are needed only for the camera to physically drive autofocus. The camera’s focus-detection system can still indicate when the subject is in focus in manual focus mode.
So a Dandelion chip can be useful for manual-focus lenses because it lets the camera recognize a lens is attached and use metering/focus-confirm behavior. It does not turn the lens into an AF-S lens and will not make the camera autofocus screw-drive or manual lenses.
If you didn’t see confirmation with the 28-80mm, that may be because those autofocus-era lenses often have very light, low-drag focusing rings, making it easy to overshoot the exact focus point by hand. A true manual-focus lens is often easier to focus precisely.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI8y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Which Nikon DSLRs have a built-in autofocus motor for older AF lenses?
Does the Nikon D7000 have a screw-drive AF motor, and does AF noise matter for video?
Why do some Canon and Nikon manual-lens adapters need an AF-confirmation chip?
Can a Nikon AF-S or AF-P lens with a failed focus motor still autofocus on a body with an internal AF motor?
Will a Nikon body with a built-in AF motor autofocus manual-focus lenses?