Why does this lens produce oval, swirly bokeh toward the edges of the frame?

Asked 6/18/2014

1 views

2 answers

0

I noticed that photos made with a Mamiya C330 and 80mm f/2.8 lens show out-of-focus highlights that are round near the center but become oval toward the edges, with the long axis tangent to the frame. The effect almost looks like rotational blur, but the in-focus foreground is sharp, so it seems to be optical rather than camera movement.

What causes this kind of non-uniform bokeh, does it have a name, and how can you intentionally get a similar look?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

22

The shape of the bokeh is related to the apparent shape of the aperture of the lens.

Straight on, this will produce a bokeh that is approximately a circle. As the subject moves away from the center of the field, the bokeh starts to look like a sliver of the circle.

This can be reduced by stopping down the lens.

lenses

More on this can be read at Shape of the blur patch and Cat's eye effect.

To achieve this affect, you need a wider field of view in the lens (a long lens will never see the aperture from a steep angle) and shoot wide open.


The optics of this can be understood by looking at the light rays through the lens system:

light path through lens

However, its not quite this simple as the lens construction itself also plays into the shape of the bokeh.

four lenses, four bokeh

The only difference between the four images is the lens. Each lens has a different front and rear pupil size and lens blade count and shape. If this effect wasn't caused by the lens, then it would indicate some other phenomena. But instead, we do see a difference between different lenses on the same camera indicating that the lens construction is the cause for the shape and the place one should look to understand the nature of this bokeh.

Ultimately, the cat's eye bokeh is a form of mechanical vignetting similar to when the lens hood is too long for the lens and blocks some of the scene.

This type of bokeh can also be seen in the apparent changing of the shape in DIY bokeh shape filters:

image image

Note the shape of the heart and mickey mouse at the edge of the frame. If one was to go and look at the lens from those point light sources, one would see that the shape of the heart or mickey mouse on the camera is the shape of the bokeh (with some additional adjustments for the apparent shape of the pupil).

Originally by user13451. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user13451

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

This is mainly the cat’s-eye / swirly bokeh effect. Off-axis blur circles change shape because, near the edges of the frame, the aperture is viewed at an angle and is partly vignetted by the lens, so round blur discs become oval or “slivered.”

In some lenses, especially older or less-corrected designs, field curvature / Petzval behavior can strengthen the look, giving the classic “swirly” rendering around the edges.

Why it happens most strongly here:

  • lens used wide open or near wide open
  • off-center background highlights
  • a lens design with noticeable off-axis vignetting / Petzval character
  • larger image format can make the edge behavior more visible

How to get it deliberately:

  • shoot wide open
  • use a lens with known swirly or cat’s-eye bokeh character
  • include small bright background highlights near the frame edges
  • use a wider field of view rather than a long telephoto
  • stopping down usually reduces the effect

So the look is not motion blur; it’s a combination of off-axis aperture shape, vignetting, and possibly field curvature/Petzval rendering.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer