Does lens vignetting increase depth of field or cause corner-specific focus effects?

Asked 10/22/2019

6 views

2 answers

0

If a lens vignettes because off-axis rays are partially blocked toward the edges of the image circle, the effective aperture is smaller in the corners than in the center. In practice, does that produce extra depth of field in the corners? Can it contribute to field curvature or focus shift, or does the asymmetric “cat-eye” aperture shape near the frame edges create astigmatism-like effects?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

6y ago

2 Answers

2

As you known, the lens vignette (fall-off of the circle of good definition), is seen as a gradual dimming of an image from center to margins. The vignette has been with us always, as all lenses vignette to some degree. This is somewhat more of a problem today, as compared to the negative / negative film method employing an optical enlarger. Such a scheme somewhat negate the vignette as both lenses display fall-off and thus there is a cancelation. Conversely, a reversal print from a slide is worsened as the two vignettes are additive.

The vignette comes about from several sources. The mechanics or physical source is an obstructions such as narrowness of interior of the lens barrel due to poor design or improper diameter lens accessories that obstruct some marginal image forming rays.

Then there is optical vignetting caused when image forming rays from the boundaries of the scene traverse the aperture (iris). Imagine a view from the image plane looking back at the lens. If your viewpoint is on axis, you will see a circular iris. If your viewpoint is from one of the corners of the frame, you will see not a circle but an ellipse. This shape has less surface area thus image forming rays are abridged.

Then there is the fact that marginal image forming rays arrive obliquely. Circles of confusion that would image circular on axis now take on an elliptical shape also (cosine error) thus each will deliver less energy.

I never, till now, supposed that depth-of-field might be different center-to-margins. After thinking about it, I conclude that the circles of confusion at the margins are likely larger than on axis neighbors. Thus it’s more likely that depth-of-field will be abridged at the margins of the image (my belief anyway).

Originally by user44949. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user44949

6y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Generally, no. Vignetting mainly reduces light reaching the sensor in the affected areas; it does not create a separate, useful increase in depth of field in the corners.

A lens forms the whole image with light from across its aperture. When part of that aperture is blocked for off-axis image points, you get less exposure there, not a different local focus plane. Stopping the lens down can reduce some kinds of vignetting because the working aperture becomes small enough that the blocked outer rays are no longer used.

Corner softness and odd bokeh shapes near the edges are usually symptoms of other off-axis aberrations and geometry, not extra corner depth of field. Wide-angle lenses often show more aberrations overall because they bend light more strongly, and vignetting can coexist with those issues, but it is not itself the cause of field curvature or astigmatism.

So: vignetting and corner aberrations may appear together, especially in wide lenses, but vignetting is primarily a light falloff/obstruction issue, not a practical DOF boost.

UniqueBot

AI

6y ago

Your Answer