Why do objects near the corners of a top-down photo look stretched or larger?

Asked 5/7/2018

4 views

2 answers

0

When I take a top-down photo with a smartphone held horizontally in landscape orientation from about 3–4 ft above a scene, objects near the center look normal, but objects near the edges or corners appear enlarged or stretched.

I tested this by placing a ruler near the top-right corner and measuring its length in pixels in GIMP. The pixel count per 5 cm stayed roughly constant for the first part of the ruler, but increased for sections farther toward the corner.

There is no obvious vignetting or visible bending of straight lines. What causes this apparent increase in size near the edges—perspective, lens distortion, field of view, or some other optical effect?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

8y ago

2 Answers

6

This is perspective distortion, and it is an inevitable outcome of projecting a three-d world onto a flat surface. See What is the difference between perspective distortion and barrel or pincushion distortion? for some details on different kinds of distortion, and How to correct perspective and geometric distortion? for what you can do about it.

Many people think that this is a property of wide-angle lenses, but that's not actually the case. It's just more apparent because with a wide angle lens you're putting closer objects from, well, a wider angle into the frame. If you change where you stand and use zoom or a different lens to get a similar framing, the perspective distortion will be different. On the other hand, no matter what you do with lenses, there's no way to change the perspective without literally changing your perspective by moving.

Try this: put your head where your camera is and look straight down. If there's an object right below you, you'll see just the top and none of its sides. But if you look over to the left or right, you'll see a bit of the sides of objects a foot or so away from the center — and quite a lot of the sides of objects further than that.

To avoid the problem, you'll need to either:

  • move the camera much further away — in your case, much higher — so everything is mostly top-down, or
  • move the camera back and forth, getting the top from multiple locations, and then stitching together, or
  • use software to stretch things to look like you want them. (Depending on the scene, this may work well enough.)

Originally by user1943. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1943

8y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

This is mainly perspective distortion, not a sensor issue. A camera projects a 3D scene onto a flat 2D image, so parts of the scene that are closer to the camera appear larger, and parts farther away appear smaller. In a top-down setup, anything not exactly parallel to the sensor plane or located off-axis can show changing scale across the frame.

Wide-angle smartphone lenses make this effect more noticeable because they include a larger field of view. People often blame the lens, but perspective is primarily determined by camera position relative to the scene. Changing focal length only changes framing unless you also change camera distance.

Lens distortion such as barrel or pincushion distortion can also affect edge geometry, but if you don’t see obvious curved straight lines, perspective is likely the dominant cause here.

To reduce the effect:

  • keep the camera perfectly parallel to the subject plane
  • place the subject closer to the center
  • move farther away and crop, or use a longer focal length if available
  • apply perspective/lens correction in software if needed

UniqueBot

AI

8y ago

Your Answer