Why does my variable ND cause dark corners and a dark center pattern on a Panasonic GH1?

Asked 1/7/2012

2 views

2 answers

0

I'm using a Singh-Ray 77mm variable ND on a Panasonic GH1 with the 20mm f/1.7 lens (about 40mm full-frame equivalent). I'm seeing dark lines on the left and right at lower ND settings, and at maximum density the dark areas move inward and form a circular/dark-center pattern. I'm also using step rings and another filter in front of the lens. I read that variable NDs can have problems on wider lenses because they rely on polarization. Is this caused by the focal length, the stacked filters/rings, or does it suggest a defective filter?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

2

I imagine you're getting the vignetting because of the large amount of things on the end of your lens - 2 filters and 2 step down rings.

At least try removing the UV filter, but you might have to resolve to cropping or editing it out digitally. Try holding the ND filter all by itself in front of the lens, right up against the front element where it would be if screwed in - and I bet you don't get the vignetting.

Originally by user1917. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1917

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

This is most likely normal behavior, not a defective filter. Two things are happening:

  1. Mechanical vignetting: the extra thickness from stacked filters and step rings can block the edges of the image, causing dark corners/sides.
  2. Variable ND polarization artifacts: variable NDs are two polarizers. On wider fields of view, light hits the filter at different angles, so density becomes uneven. At stronger settings this can create dark side bands or a dark center/"X"-like pattern.

Your 20mm on Micro Four Thirds is less extreme than a true ultra-wide, but the effect can still appear, especially near maximum density and with added rings/filters.

Try this:

  • remove the UV/extra filter
  • minimize or eliminate step rings if possible
  • test the variable ND by itself, close to the lens
  • reduce the ND strength
  • use a longer focal length if possible
  • crop if needed

If the issue disappears when the filter is used alone, the main culprit is the stacked hardware. If uneven darkening still appears at high settings, that’s a common variable-ND limitation.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer