How can I avoid vignetting from a 77mm variable ND filter on wide-angle lenses?
Asked 10/29/2012
1 views
2 answers
0
I’m using a Nikon D700 with a 24-70mm and a 28-300mm lens, plus a 77mm variable ND filter. I’m seeing dark corners from the filter, especially at the wide end. What causes this, and how can I reduce or avoid the vignetting?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
13y ago
2 Answers
3
It's an angle of view issue. The light path is intercepted at the frame corners by parts of the filter blocking parts of the light path.
If you wish to use a filter at extreme settings and a standard version causes vignetting then you need either
A wider active area of filter at a given distance from your lens front surface (which may not be possible without machining your lens front !!!, or
To mount the filter element closer to the lens (which again may not be possible with major surgery.
If you are using another filter between lens and ND filter it will add to vignetting effect - take it off.
You could fabricate a stop that presents the lens entering the focal length range where vignetting occurs - messy and prone to either be not used when needed or left in place when not needed.
If you are serious and desperate enough you can probably fabricate or have fabricated a custom mount that uses the ND material from the existing filter and mounts it in a ring which is either broader or shallower. However, given that many other filters do not cause vignetting at short focal lengths, chances are that either you are doing something fixable or the filter manufacturer has a bad design.
You MAY be able to modify the ND filter without changing to a custom mount.View the vignetting effect at minimum focal length. Now, remove the filter and insert a flat stick (iceblock stick about right) into the corner of the field of view and adjust position until it gives similar depth of vignetting penetration to the filter ring. This shows you how much intrusion you have to deal with. Next inspect the filter ring and see what needs to be done to remove the same amount of intrusion. It MAY be possible to machine the filter outer surface enough to fix it. Maybe not. Removing the ND material while you machine the ring "would be wise". If less venturesome you can reduce the ring thickness on a whetstone with time, water and elbow grease. BUT it should not be necessary if the manufacturer has done their job properly.
If you can find some other kind of filter than fits and that does not cause vignetting you MAY be able to swap the ND element into it. Or not.
Originally by user6263. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user6263
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
This is usually mechanical vignetting: at wider focal lengths, the lens sees a wider angle of view, and the filter ring can block light in the corners. That’s why it’s most noticeable around 24mm or 28mm and much less likely at longer focal lengths.
To reduce it:
- Avoid using the lens at its widest focal lengths when the filter is attached.
- Remove any extra filters stacked behind the variable ND, since stacking increases vignetting.
- Use a filter with a wider effective opening or a slimmer mount, if available.
- If possible, use a setup that places the filter closer to the lens front element.
In practice, if a standard variable ND vignettes on your wide end, there’s no camera setting that will fully fix it—the issue is physical obstruction from the filter assembly.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Do variable ND filters work well on wide-angle lenses?
Why does my variable ND filter create dark spots at 18mm?
How should I evaluate and choose a 24-70mm f/2.8 lens for Nikon?
Why does a variable ND filter cause an X-pattern and uneven darkening on a wide-angle lens?
Why are both 10-22mm and 24-70mm called wide-angle lenses on a Canon T2i?