Why does my handheld light meter overexpose a night cityscape?

Asked 12/23/2023

6 views

2 answers

0

I’m learning to use a handheld meter and got badly overexposed results on a night cityscape. I was shooting at ISO 100 and f/11 on a Canon EOS R5, using a Sekonic L-758D in both incident mode (the dome/sphere) and spot mode. When I metered what I thought was a midtone area, the photo came out roughly 2 stops too bright.

Why would this happen? Is incident metering inappropriate for city lights at night, and how should I use spot metering correctly in this kind of scene?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

2y ago

2 Answers

2

Let me use a different scenario, a studio setup.

The incident light meter (sphere) measures how much light comes to a scene. The incident light knows nothing about your product's color on the table. It can be some white shoes or black ones.

But a reflected light measure is affected now by what the object on the table is, but the measure does not know what it is. Does not know if it is a white or black object, so its goal is to assume it is gray.

I read your comment on the zone system. And you are right. The zone system gives us a hint on what tone overall is what we are seeing and provides that information to whatever setup we are dealing with.

enter image description here

In this case, the compensation means that we are not seeing a green grassfield during daytime, which we could expect to turn gray on a black-and-white photo, but a nighttime when we need that zone to be mostly black.

The same would be true when measuring a white beach zone or snow, or if we need a high-key photograph or low-key one.


On a cityscape is quite hard to define where the midpoint is. You probably have deep blacks, but that depends on if there is haze, clouds, full moon, etc. And you probably have strong lights that are expected to blow the whites, but we do not really know the intensity of them.

It makes no sense to measure a dark spot and define it as a zone 0 because it tells you nothing about how deep the deep black is. So in some cases, IMHO, the spot metering is not really useful, unless you really have an illuminated zone, like a specific wall that is on the frame. Otherwise, it is probably a good idea to adapt a generic rule like the Sunny 16 rule and compensate for the necessary EV steps.

Originally by user37321. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user37321

2y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes — this is mostly a metering-method issue, not the camera’s ISO rating.

For a night cityscape, incident metering with the dome is usually not useful. Incident meters measure light falling onto a subject, but in a city-at-night scene many bright elements are the light sources themselves, not normally lit surfaces.

Spot metering can work, but the Sekonic’s 1° spot is very narrow, so finding a true midtone in a night scene is difficult. Like any reflected meter, it assumes what you meter should render as middle gray. If you meter a bright sign or lamp-lit area and use that reading directly, the meter may try to make it gray, which can push the overall exposure the wrong way for the scene.

A better approach is to meter something specific and place it intentionally:

  • bright area you want bright but not blown: give it more exposure than the meter reading
  • dark area you want near black: give it less exposure than the meter reading

So yes, you’re likely “doing something wrong” only in the sense that night scenes need deliberate tone placement, not a straight meter reading from a guessed midtone.

UniqueBot

AI

2y ago

Your Answer