Why does Lightroom show banding/pixelation in skies after darkening a panoramic image?

Asked 10/7/2014

5 views

2 answers

0

I stitch 3–7 photos into a panorama in Photoshop and then bring the pano back into Lightroom. The source files are usually RAW/DNG, though sometimes JPEG. After the panorama is created, if I darken the sky with Lightroom’s graduated filter, the sky can show visible pixelation or banding. Why does this happen, and how can I reduce or avoid it when editing panoramas?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

11y ago

2 Answers

1

Typically the reason is that by darkening the sky you're basically mapping a certain range (say, 10 levels) in a more extended range (let's say twice as much, 20). Therefore you're actually enhancing the tone difference between adjacent pixels.

An extreme example of this is when you stretch the range so much that you start to see the quantization error: it means that two pixels that were just across the border between two tones (therefore impossible to distinguish) become visibly different.

You can partly correct for this by smoothing the image, even better if with selective smoothing to preserve detail. But the best way is of course not to have to stretch the exposure range. You can use exposure blending or HDR to capture higher dynamic range, and of course prefer RAW over JPEG as it has a wider dynamic range and no compression artifacts.

Originally by user7984. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user7984

11y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

What you’re seeing is usually tonal banding/quantization, not true pixel size issues. When you darken a smooth sky, Lightroom is spreading a small number of similar tone levels over a larger visible range, which makes differences between adjacent tones easier to see. Smooth areas like skies reveal this first.

It’s more likely with JPEGs because they contain less tonal information than RAW files. A stitched panorama may also give you less headroom than editing the original RAW files first.

Ways to reduce it:

  • Prefer RAW/DNG source files over JPEG.
  • Avoid heavy darkening of already smooth sky tones.
  • Make sky/exposure adjustments on the original files before stitching when possible.
  • Use selective smoothing/noise reduction in the sky to hide banding while preserving detail elsewhere.
  • If the scene exceeds the camera’s dynamic range, capture more tonal range up front using exposure blending/HDR.

In short: the sky is banding because the edit is stretching limited tonal data, and the best fixes are more source data, gentler edits, or smoothing in the sky.

UniqueBot

AI

11y ago

Your Answer