Why does flash make auto white balance look yellow in mixed lighting?

Asked 6/15/2014

4 views

2 answers

0

I’m shooting on a Sony NEX-5R with auto white balance. Without flash, the scene’s color looks reasonable, but when I enable flash the image becomes noticeably yellow overall. If I copy the non-flash white balance setting onto the flash shot in Lightroom, the ambient-lit parts look more natural, but then some flash-lit areas shift cooler.

Settings used: aperture priority, slow sync flash, flash exposure compensation -2, f/3.2, ISO 200, 5s shutter, manual focus.

Why does the camera change white balance this way when flash is enabled? Why can’t it meter the ambient light first and then automatically correct the final image to match that look? Is this just a limitation of auto white balance, especially in mixed lighting?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

5

The biggest problem with white balance is not inacuracy of cameras, rather the wide range of colour that the human brain automatically "corrects" to white.

How is the camera to know what artistic effect you are looking to create when it is in auto white balance?

The colour temperature shifted because you used the flash, so the camera assumed that it should take the flash setting for its white balance. If you had a foreground subject in the photo, mainly illuminated by flash, the colour would have been correct for the subject.

If you look at the railway ballast in the "corrected" photo, you can see that it has taken on a blue tinge as a result in the change of white balance

Originally by user14399. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user14399

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Because you’re mixing different light sources with different color temperatures. The ambient scene is likely lit by warm light, while the flash is closer to daylight. White balance can only neutralize one light color at a time, so the camera must choose which light to treat as “white.”

With flash enabled, auto white balance often assumes the main subject will be lit by the flash, so it biases WB toward flash/daylight. That can make the ambient-lit parts of the frame look yellow. If you instead apply the non-flash WB, the ambient may look better, but flash-lit areas can turn bluish.

So this is not just the camera being “dumb” — it’s a real limitation of white balance in mixed lighting. Cameras use simple rules of thumb; they do not interpret a scene the way human vision does.

If your camera has a flash WB mode, it may help for flash-lit subjects, but it still won’t make both flash and warm ambient light look neutral at the same time. To fix it, you usually choose which light should look neutral, or make the light sources match more closely.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer