Auto white balance vs custom white balance: why are the results different?
Asked 6/17/2013
1 views
2 answers
0
On my Canon 550D, indoor photos under fluorescent light often look yellow with Auto White Balance, while Custom White Balance gives more neutral colors. I set custom white balance by photographing a white or neutral object in the same light and using that image as the reference. How do Auto White Balance and Custom White Balance work, and why doesn't Auto White Balance usually match the custom result?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
13y ago
2 Answers
5
With Auto White Balance most cameras place a greater weight on the brightest parts of the frame. Some newer models, particularly higher end ones, also measure all of the color in each picture and compare it to a stored database. If a match is found the camera applies whatever the database tells it to. The decision is made for each photo based strictly on the content of that one photo.
With Custom White Balance the camera takes your word for it that what is in the middle of the sample picture you provide is what you want to appear as white and applies the same white balance needed to render your sample as white to each photo, whether there is anything the same color in the image or not.
Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user15871
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Auto White Balance (AWB) and Custom White Balance solve the same problem differently.
AWB makes an educated guess for each photo. The camera analyzes the scene—often giving more weight to bright areas, and on some models comparing the image to built-in scene/color data—to decide what should look neutral. Because it is guessing from the photo content, it can be fooled by unusual lighting or scenes that don’t contain reliable neutral tones. Fluorescent light is a common case where AWB may miss and leave a yellow or green cast.
Custom White Balance uses a reference image that you provide, ideally of a neutral gray or white subject lit by the same light as your scene. The camera measures that reference and calculates how to balance the red, green, and blue channels so that the reference becomes neutral. It then applies that correction consistently to your photos in that lighting.
So AWB is convenient but less precise; custom WB is more accurate because it measures the actual light instead of guessing. For best custom results, use a properly exposed neutral gray or white target and avoid clipping the whites.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why do fluorescent lights cause changing orange/white color casts at fast shutter speeds?
Why does my Canon S90 seem better than my Rebel XTi in Auto mode indoors?
How ambient light spectrum affects color rendition and white balance
How can I choose the right white balance setting in camera?
Why doesn’t Canon custom white balance carry over to Lightroom or Camera Raw?