Why does a loose camera lens seem to invert distant objects, while the camera viewfinder shows an upright image?

Asked 3/19/2012

6 views

2 answers

0

When I look through a camera lens by itself, distant objects can appear inverted, while nearby objects may look upright like with a magnifying glass. But when the lens is mounted on a camera, the viewfinder and the final photo show the scene with a consistent orientation.

Why does a single lens seem to behave differently for near and far objects, and how does the camera make the viewfinder image appear upright? Also, is the image formed by the lens itself actually inverted on the focusing screen/film/sensor?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

9

It is "easy enough" to explain the basic question with a ray diagram or similar means - see below
BUT it is important to realize that the answer to why viewfinder or human eye images are not inverted is "by design" or "because" (choose one, both the same essentially). That is to say, the system requires the outcome to be a certain way, so whatever steps are required to implement the outcome are provided.

In the case of a viewfinder, extra lenses, mirrors or prisms (or a combination of these) are added as required to achieve the final result. The real question becomes not "why is this this way up" but how is this done.

In the case of the human eye, the image on the Retina IS inverted and the brain looks at it the "right way up" as far as the viewer is concerned.

The information below from this excellent site shows how basic inversion works.

enter image description here

Also see -> More on Ray Diagrams


In the case of the eye, the image is inverted:{ From here - low tech but interesting }

enter image description here

http://www.quantumtheatre.co.uk/Lights%20&%20Sounds%20notes%20Key%20Stage%202_files/image022.jpg


IMPORTANT:

Note that while the above image grabs your attention as it demonstrates inversion, it actually does a very bad job of showing how the eye lens works. As the eye lens is increasingly embedded in the cornea, the air-cornea interaction does most of the 'lensing' while the cornea-lens interface only manages about 10% of the total bending.

An excellent discussion of this is available here - see the In your eye and a reasonably correct image of how light is actually bent by the eye is shown below.

enter image description here

Originally by user6263. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user6263

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

A single converging lens can form either:

  • a virtual, upright image for objects closer than the focal length, or
  • a real, inverted image for objects farther away.

That’s why a loose lens can seem to act like a magnifying glass for nearby subjects, but invert distant ones.

In a camera, the lens forms a real image on the film, sensor, or focusing screen. That image is inverted. Close objects that would only form a virtual image are not focused onto the film/sensor in that state; if you can still see them through the mounted camera, they will be blurred unless focus is adjusted appropriately.

The reason the viewfinder looks upright is that the camera adds optical parts specifically to reorient the image—typically mirrors and/or a pentaprism/pentamirror in an SLR-style finder. Those components flip the already inverted image so you see it correctly.

For the human eye, the image formed on the retina is also inverted, but the brain interprets it as upright.

So yes: the lens itself can produce upright virtual images at close range and inverted real images at longer distances; the camera viewfinder corrects the orientation by design.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer