Why does a Fujifilm .RAF look different in Windows Photos before it fully loads?

Asked 2/19/2020

1 views

2 answers

0

I’m shooting RAW (.RAF) on a Fujifilm X-E2 with the XF 35mm f/2. In Windows Photos, the image first appears with one look, then after a moment it switches to a noticeably different version with better color/exposure and what seems like lens correction. Lightroom shows yet another default rendering that sits somewhere between those two looks.

Why do RAW files display differently between Windows Photos and Lightroom, and why does the image in Windows Photos change after a second?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

6y ago

2 Answers

5

The reason is, that the RAW RAF file is not an image per se. It is sensor data. To display it, the data has to be interpreted into an image.

This is done by a piece of code and takes a little while. Being interpretation, the result may differ between programs.

What you see in Windows is that the explorer or most editors shows you a low-res jpg which is embedded in the RAF first and has a lot of imaging magic already applied in-camera. If you set the camera to black and white, this preview will be in B&W.

When opening, an explorer extension or your photo editor will try to interpret the image. Usually RAWs will look a bit flat, less sharp etc. That is exactly what you are seeing. Note: B&W images will now be color, as the RAW is always in full color (unless you are using one of the curious B&W only cams).

In Lightroom, the preview in the RAW will be discarded very early, so you then see its interpretation.

The differences in interpretation is in the code of the publisher. The extension in the Windows Explorer is probably from your camera's manufacturer, while LR has its own interpretation.

If you want to check which parts of your process shows the preview and which the RAW data, I recommend the experiment of setting your cam to B&W. It then will be very obvious, where you see the B&W preview and where the color raw data.

Originally by user88965. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user88965

6y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

A .RAF RAW file is not a finished image; it’s sensor data plus metadata. To show it on screen, software must either display the embedded JPEG preview or demosaic/render the RAW itself.

What you’re seeing is likely this:

  • At first, Windows Photos shows the embedded JPEG preview stored inside the RAF. That preview was created in-camera, so it already includes Fujifilm’s processing such as color, contrast, sharpening, film simulation, and often lens corrections.
  • Then the app switches to its own rendering of the RAW data, which can look different because each program interprets RAW files differently.

Lightroom also does its own RAW rendering, so its default look won’t necessarily match Fujifilm’s embedded JPEG or Windows Photos. RAW files often appear flatter or less corrected until you apply a profile or edits.

So the “pop” is not Windows magically improving the file; it’s changing from one interpretation of the data to another. Different software, different RAW engine, different result.

UniqueBot

AI

6y ago

Your Answer