Why do NEF raw files look different in Windows Photos, Photo Viewer, and Photoshop?

Asked 4/18/2014

3 views

2 answers

0

When I open a Nikon D80 .NEF file in Windows Photos, it first appears with one look, but after zooming in and back out it seems to re-render with lower saturation and contrast. Windows Photo Viewer shows yet another slightly different version, and if I open the NEF in Photoshop and save it as JPEG, the result looks somewhere in between.

Is this because some apps initially show the embedded JPEG preview from the NEF and then switch to their own raw rendering? Why do different programs show different color and contrast from the same NEF file?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

2

The JPG image embedded in the NEF file is just one way of interpreting the raw information to make a final picture. It is the automatic conversion done in the camera. This is the conversion used to show you what the picture looks like on the monitor in the camera. They have to pick something. Nikon also encrypts the information so that you can't do the same conversion without the decription key.

This in-camera conversion does take the ambient light color into account, so it's usually not too bad, but it is certainly not the single right answer. The automatic process has no idea what parts of the picture are important to you or what you are trying to show.

Some software may do its own default conversion from the raw data, sometimes just because it doesn't do the decryption. In any case, the JPG picture is just meant as a quick basic way to show you the picture, not as your final picture. It therefore doesn't matter what the camera did or what various software programs do. They all fill the purpose of showing you the picture. Beyond that, the JPG picture is irrelevant, as is any other automated preview derived from the raw data. Ultimately you have to decide what you really want and steer the conversion process accordingly.

Originally by user7603. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user7603

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes. A NEF contains raw sensor data plus an embedded JPEG preview generated in-camera. That preview reflects Nikon’s own processing choices, such as picture settings, white balance, contrast, saturation, and color profile.

Many apps first display the embedded JPEG because it is fast. When you zoom or the app finishes loading, it may switch to rendering the raw data itself. At that point the look can change because raw data is not a finished image—it must be interpreted.

Different programs use different raw-conversion algorithms and default settings, so the same NEF can look different in Windows Photos, Windows Photo Viewer, Photoshop, Lightroom, darktable, etc. Some software can closely match or extract the embedded JPEG; others render from the raw data with their own defaults, which often gives flatter contrast or less saturation until adjusted.

So the discrepancy is normal: you are comparing the camera’s JPEG rendering with one or more software interpretations of the raw file.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer