Why do TTL flashes use a pre-flash, and why is flash exposure compensation still needed?

Asked 8/2/2012

6 views

2 answers

0

I understand that flash exposure depends on aperture, ISO, and subject distance, so it seems like a subject in black clothing and one in white clothing at the same distance should need the same flash output. If that's true, why does E-TTL/TTL need to fire a pre-flash to measure the scene? And why do photographers still need to use flash exposure compensation for subjects or scenes that aren’t midtones?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

10

The camera doesn't know the distance of all subjects - only a rough estimate of the distance to which the lens is focused. The camera also does not know the exact flash head angle, it may be the case that you are bouncing the flash of the ceiling, or there may be other surfaces in the scene that reflect light back onto the subject.

Flash exposure compensation is required exactly because the camera doesn't know the colour of the objects in the scene, and therefore how much light to expect back. It can only make the standard metering assumption of 18% reflectivity.

Firing off a preflash and measuring light returning through the lens is still the best way to judge the required flash output for a correct(ish) exposure.

Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1375

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

TTL uses a pre-flash because the camera usually does not know enough to calculate flash power from distance alone. It may only know an approximate focus distance, not the distance to every part of the scene, and it also can’t fully account for how the flash is being used—direct, bounced off a ceiling/wall, zoomed to a certain beam angle, or affected by nearby reflective surfaces.

Those factors change how much light actually returns through the lens. For example, the same subject may need different flash output outdoors versus in a small room with white walls, because the room adds reflected light.

Flash exposure compensation is still needed because TTL metering, like other reflected-light metering, makes a standard assumption about scene reflectance (roughly a midtone/18% gray). If the subject or scene is unusually dark or bright, the meter can be fooled, so you may need to tell it to give more or less flash than its default estimate.

So: distance matters, but it is not the whole problem. The pre-flash measures the real scene and lighting path, and FEC lets you override the meter’s midtone assumption.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer