Why do Nikon TTL flash photos get brighter when I change exposure compensation?

Asked 4/10/2012

4 views

2 answers

0

I shot four images on a Nikon D300 in shutter-priority mode at 1/250s, f/5.3, ISO 400 using the built-in pop-up flash in TTL. The only setting I changed was exposure compensation, from -4 EV to +2 EV. Flash exposure compensation stayed the same.

Even though the shutter speed, aperture, and ISO are unchanged, the images become progressively brighter as exposure compensation increases. EXIF shows the flash was TTL metered, and Active D-Lighting was set to Normal.

Why does this happen? Does Nikon exposure compensation change TTL flash output as well as ambient exposure, or is the camera applying some JPEG processing afterward?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

4

With Nikon, Exposure Compensation affects the overall exposure, including any automatically metered flash, while Flash Exposure Compensation (when available) affects only the flash's contribution to the overall exposure.

If the scene weren't essentially a flat plane (there isn't much depth to the scene at all), you could use Exposure Compensation to bring down the entire exposure, then boost the flash exposure to correctly expose your main subject. That would isolate the subject from the background. (The opposite can be set in theory, but it won't work unless and until somebody invents a "flash" that subtracts light from the ambient exposure.) More often, though, you'd use the Exposure compensation to compensate for the tonality of the scene (bumping it up for scenes consisting mostly of lighter tones or lowering it for predominantly dark scenes), then independently adjust the flash (usually downward) to add the desired amount of fill.

Note that with these pictures, there isn't much contribution to the exposure from ambient light at all, so if you had set the Exposure compensation to -1 EV and the Flash Exposure Compensation to +1 EV, you would have gotten pretty much the same picture as the normal exposure.

Originally by user2719. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user2719

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

On Nikon bodies, regular exposure compensation affects the camera’s overall target exposure, and that includes TTL flash metering. So with the pop-up flash in TTL, changing exposure compensation can make the camera fire more or less flash even when shutter speed, aperture, and ISO stay the same.

That matches what you’re seeing: the flash output is changing, not the basic exposure settings.

Flash exposure compensation is separate: it adjusts only the flash contribution relative to the camera’s metered baseline. Exposure compensation shifts the whole exposure goal; flash compensation then biases the flash portion around that goal.

So in your test:

  • raising exposure compensation made the TTL system increase flash output
  • lowering exposure compensation made it reduce flash output

This is expected Nikon behavior, not a mystery change in the recorded shutter/aperture/ISO.

JPEG settings like Active D-Lighting may slightly affect tone/rendering, but they do not explain the main brightness change here. The key factor is that Nikon TTL flash is being metered differently when exposure compensation changes.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer