Why do some lenses seem to produce different colors than others?
Asked 2/22/2019
3 views
2 answers
0
Lens marketing sometimes claims a lens gives “great color.” Aside from obvious tint in the glass, what parts of lens design can affect color reproduction? Can one lens really have better color than another, or is it mostly a warm/cool color cast or saturation difference?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
7y ago
2 Answers
3
With respect to color, better is often a matter of opinion. Different wavelengths may be transmitted differently depending on lens element materials and coatings. This is most noticeable when comparing very old lenses with modern lenses. They are usually most noticeable as warmer or cooler colors when white balance is set to auto (on some cameras). However, with most modern lenses and custom white balance, differences in color are usually negligible.
As far as the Lomogon Lens is concerned, many of the sample images appear to be post processed, so it's not clear what is lens and what is post processing.
Originally by user75526. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user75526
7y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
“Better color” is mostly subjective marketing. In practice, lenses can differ in color rendering because they do not transmit all wavelengths of light equally. The main causes are the lens element materials and the coatings, which can make a lens look slightly warmer, cooler, or alter saturation a bit.
These differences are often more noticeable with older lenses than with modern ones. With most modern lenses, any color differences are usually small, and custom white balance or post-processing can largely correct them. Auto white balance may also make lens-to-lens differences seem more obvious.
So yes, lenses can produce slightly different color casts, but that is not the same as one lens having objectively “better” color. For accurate color, camera profiling, white balance, lighting, and post-processing usually matter more than the lens. Also, sample images in marketing are often edited, so it can be hard to tell what comes from the lens and what comes from post-processing.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI7y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Do different lenses affect color reproduction and fidelity?
Why can different lenses produce more or less color saturation?
How does fog affect sunrise and sunset colors?
Can camera specifications tell you how accurate the colors will be?
Can an older copy of the same lens model change color rendering over time?