Can an older copy of the same lens model change color rendering over time?
Asked 1/11/2015
3 views
2 answers
0
My friend claims that an older copy of the same lens model may produce different color than a newer one simply because the lens has aged. Is that generally true? If so, what parts of a lens could age or wear in a way that affects color transmission?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
11y ago
2 Answers
16
In general, lenses do not degrade in this way. However, some old lenses made up until the 1970s contain elements made of thorium oxide — a radioactive element which yellows as it ages. These were used because they have a different refractive index, with low dispersion — so, generally, better-quality lenses, just as fluorite crystal or other exotic elements are used today. It's also possible that adhesives (used to bond lens elements to each other) or coatings used in older lenses may yellow as they age. In both of these cases, if there's enough effect to make a difference, you should see it when just looking through the lens.
The other difference may be in newer lens designs vs. older ones. This shouldn't affect the case your friend is talking about (same model over time), but may be the source of the confusion. Design of coatings changes, as does the types of glass used. And this can be very strong between manufacturers — for example, while I haven't found this anywhere official, many people believe Sigma intentionally introduces a slight color warming effect in their lenses.
Originally by user1943. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1943
11y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Usually, no. A lens of the same model does not normally change color noticeably just because it is older. Lens glass generally does not discolor with age, and coatings are so thin that any normal aging effect is minimal.
There are a few exceptions with some older lenses. Certain lenses made up to around the 1970s used thorium-containing glass, which can yellow over time. In some cases, old adhesives or coatings may also yellow. If that happens strongly enough to matter, you can often see the tint just by looking through the lens.
In practical use, any small color shift from lens aging is usually much smaller than changes caused by ambient light, and it can generally be corrected with normal white balance workflow, such as using a gray or white reference shot.
So for the same lens model, age alone is usually not a meaningful cause of different color rendering, except for uncommon aging issues in some older lenses.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI11y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Did Canon update later production of the EF-S 55-250mm f/4-5.6, or are older copies the same?
Do digital cameras lose image quality over time?
Does a full-frame DSLR always produce better image quality than an APS-C DSLR?
Do modern lenses change optically during a model’s production run?
Can a simple prime lens render better contrast and color than a complex zoom at the same settings?