Why do some lens hoods have a petal or tulip shape?

Asked 3/19/2014

4 views

2 answers

0

I often see petal-shaped lens hoods, especially on zoom lenses. I understand that a hood is meant to block stray light from outside the image area to reduce flare, so I would expect a simple round hood to work best.

Why are some hoods cut into a tulip/petal shape instead of being fully round? What advantage does that shape provide, and how is it related to focal length or the lens’s angle of view?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

5

The tulip shape is designed for the shortest focal length and therefore fore the widest angle that your lens supports.

Look though it with your eye where the camera lens would be and you see that the shape of the hood is -very roughly- a rectangle. Doing so try to imagine how a round shaped hood of the same size would shade the corners of the image.

Thinking this though you will quickly come to the result that such a lens is less than optimal for any of the longer focal length of your zoom lens. It is advisable using a different hood at its long end.

Originally by user17711. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user17711

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Petal-shaped hoods are designed to block as much stray light as possible without appearing in the frame at the lens’s widest angle of view.

Because the image area is rectangular, the lens can tolerate a deeper hood at the top and bottom (and sometimes sides) than it can at the corners. A round hood deep enough to give the same shading would vignette the image corners on the wide end. The petal cutouts remove material where the corners need clearance, while leaving more hood depth where it can still help.

This matters most on zooms: the hood is usually designed for the shortest focal length, since that is the most demanding in terms of avoiding vignetting. That means the hood is a compromise and is less effective at the longer focal lengths than a dedicated hood for just the tele end would be.

So the cuts are not there to help by themselves—they let the hood stay deeper overall without intruding into the picture.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer