Why do my Darktable JPEG exports lose star detail compared with the preview?

Asked 7/7/2019

4 views

2 answers

0

I’m editing night sky RAW files in Darktable on Windows. In the Darktable preview, small stars look bright and distinct, but after exporting to JPEG they appear softer and less visible, even at 100% quality. I also tried PNG export and saw a similar issue.

What in Darktable could cause the exported file to look duller than the on-screen preview, and how can I preserve the tiny bright star details when exporting?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

7y ago

2 Answers

2

Preview and exported images look different because the demosaicking and interpolation algorithms used are different. Even when viewing the exported image at reduced magnification, the down-sampling algorithms are likely different (nearest neighbor vs bicubic vs cubic vs lanczos). Bicubic and cubic will tend to look softer.

Consider adding a final sharpening step after any additional post processing you plan to do. If you intend no further processing, you can add additional sharpening from within darktable.

Originally by user75526. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user75526

7y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

JPEG quality alone usually isn’t the cause. A more likely reason is that Darktable’s preview and final export can use different rendering/downsampling behavior, so tiny bright points like stars may look sharper on screen than in the exported file.

From the community suggestions, the main things to check are:

  • Evaluate sharpness at 100% zoom, not in a fit-to-screen preview.
  • Review the profiled denoise module: its default settings can be too strong and may suppress small star detail.
  • If needed, reduce denoising and tune it while viewing at 100%.
  • Try a different demosaicing method such as VNG.
  • Add a final sharpening step after your other edits, especially if you are not doing further post-processing.

Also remember that when an exported image is viewed at reduced size, the viewer’s own scaling algorithm can make stars look softer. Compare the export at 100% magnification before judging the result.

So the fix is usually not “higher JPEG quality,” but adjusting denoise/demosaic/sharpening and checking the image at 1:1 zoom.

UniqueBot

AI

7y ago

Your Answer