Why are camera flash bursts so short instead of staying on for the whole exposure?
Asked 7/15/2018
4 views
2 answers
0
I learned that most photographic flashes emit very brief pulses, often around 1/1000s or shorter, rather than staying on for the entire shutter time. Why are they designed that way? If a flash could turn on before the shutter opens and stay on until after it closes, it seems like flash sync issues would disappear. What are the technical and photographic reasons for using such short flash durations instead of effectively continuous light?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
8y ago
2 Answers
21
That is a true statement, but it misses the big point. (As the shutter would see it), it would simply become continuous light, like any incandescent light bulb (always On for the full shutter duration would be indistinguishable from continuous light). Like continuous light, there would be no motion stopping ability at all.
And even a 500 watt light bulb at 1/200 second shutter is 500 x 1/200 = 2.5 watt seconds of power input, also with very low output efficiency. The regular camera speedlight might be 75 watt seconds, with several times higher output efficiency, and vastly greater light ouput. And is fast, and is vastly more convenient to use than the 500 watt light bulb. Hollywood movies must use continuous lights, but they also have large trucks carrying huge power generators.
But your description is exactly what High-Speed Sync is (HSS), a "flash mode" optionally offered by some cameras and some camera flashes to mimic continuous light (to avoid sync issues). So HSS is a choice if you want to buy it, and want to suffer with its large limitations (of speed and power). But it is merely high speed sync (meaning a fast shutter speed can be used since there is no sync issue), but HSS is the full opposite of high speed flash. No shutter speed can be as fast as a speedlight can be. And continuous light lasting for that longer shutter speed duration would require excessive power (so HSS Mode typically must run at no more than around 20% power level of speedlight mode). Conversely, speedlights simply discharge a large capacitor as a very fast pulse. Which is typically relatively slow at Full power level, but speedlights are called speedlights because they are greatly faster at lower power levels.
The regular normal camera flash mode is called a speedlight (all camera flashes are speedlight type, but only a few studio flashes are) become even much faster at lower power level settings, perhaps 1/30,000 second at maybe 1/64 power. Which is ideal to stop motion like milk drop splashes or hummingbird wings, where the flash can be close to the action. See my site at https://www.scantips.com/speed.html
Flash is often somewhat faster than 1/1000 second, which has great advantage to stop motion, and to offer high peak power for an instant. Photographing the running playing kids when using a speedlight as bounce flash at say 1/2 power will be 1/1000 second duration, and will stop action quite well (even if the default shutter speed is 1/60 second). That assumes indoors, where the ambient continuous light is too weak to show any motion blur.
Originally by user38978. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user38978
8y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Because a flash is meant to deliver a lot of light in a very short time. To the camera, a light that stays on for the whole exposure is basically just continuous light, which means it loses one of flash’s biggest advantages: freezing motion.
Most flashes work by dumping energy from a capacitor through a xenon tube. That creates a very bright burst, but only briefly. Keeping that arc going longer would require much more power, generate much more heat, and be hard on the tube—especially for battery-powered units.
A short flash pulse is also far more efficient for photography: it can produce much higher peak light output than a practical continuous lamp, while using manageable energy.
Continuous-on lighting does exist, including LED-based phone “flash” systems and studio/video lights. These avoid the classic flash-burst behavior, but they do not give the same motion-stopping power per unit of energy, and to get comparable brightness you generally need much more power and more heat management.
So short flash duration isn’t just a limitation—it’s a key feature of photographic flash.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI8y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why does the aperture open and close when taking a photo in Live View on a Nikon D7000?
Why can’t a normal flash exceed X-sync just by staying on during shutter travel?
Why do some modern speedlights list longer full-power flash durations than older flashes?
Why is flash sync speed slower than flash duration?
Why use mirror lock-up for long exposures, and when does it actually help?