Which Canon entry-level DSLR is closest to the Nikon D3100, and should I switch systems for it?
Asked 10/14/2010
5 views
2 answers
0
I'm choosing my first entry-level DSLR for general photography (landscapes, portraits, everyday use) with only casual video needs. I was leaning toward Canon because friends use Canon, so lens sharing and advice would be easier.
The Canon models I'm considering are the EOS 1000D, 500D, and 550D. The 1000D feels dated and lacks video. The 500D seems to hit a good price point, but the 550D has better overall specs for a moderate price increase. Meanwhile, the Nikon D3100 looks attractive because it seems to offer a strong mix of stills and video at an entry-level price.
My questions are:
- Which Canon model is the closest match to the Nikon D3100 in price/features?
- Is it worth choosing Nikon over Canon just for the D3100 body, given that I haven't invested in lenses yet?
- Between the Canon 1000D and 500D, which makes more sense?
- Is buying the 1000D as a temporary body and upgrading later a bad idea?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
15y ago
2 Answers
10
If you're new to DSLRs, it's worth sticking with the brand your friends use; not just so you can borrow stuff, but for the free advice as well.
Originally by user1615. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1615
15y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
The closest Canon option discussed here is the EOS 500D, with the 550D as the stronger but more expensive step up. Based on the answers, the 500D is the best fit if you want a sensible balance of price, still-image quality, and usable video.
The main advice is: don’t choose a whole system around one entry-level body. Camera bodies change quickly, but lenses, compatibility, and the support you get from friends matter longer. Since your friends use Canon, staying with Canon gives you practical advantages: borrowing lenses, sharing knowledge, and easier help getting started.
Between the 1000D and 500D, the 500D is the better choice if the 1000D already feels limiting. The 1000D is older, more dated, and lacks video, so buying it as a stopgap is likely false economy if you expect to upgrade soon.
Unless you have a specific need the Canon bodies can’t meet, switching to Nikon just for the D3100 probably doesn’t make sense. For casual video, the 500D should be adequate, and if your budget comfortably allows it, the 550D is the more future-proof Canon choice.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI15y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Canon 500D with 18-55 + 75-300, or 550D with 18-55 IS: which is the better starter kit?
What cameras from Nikon, Sony, or Pentax compare to the Canon 1000D for a first DSLR?
Should I buy a used Canon 40D or a new Canon 1000D as my first DSLR?
Which is better for short video: Canon EOS 500D or Nikon D3100?
Can Canon EOS and Nikon DSLR lenses be used interchangeably?