Can Canon EOS and Nikon DSLR lenses be used interchangeably?

Asked 8/29/2010

2 views

2 answers

0

I'm choosing between a Nikon D5000 and a Canon EOS 500D/550D, and I'm wondering about lens sharing. For example, can a Canon EF-S 18-55mm kit lens be used on a Nikon DSLR, or a Nikon DSLR lens on a Canon EOS body? I'm mainly asking about recent DSLR lenses rather than older manual-focus systems, and whether adapters make this practical for everyday use.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

16y ago

2 Answers

13

Nikon has the longest flange to focal-plane distance, so you can't use lenses meant for other 35mm lens-mounts on Nikon cameras (the lens would be too far from the sensor/film to focus to infinity). The exception might be if you were doing closeup/macro photography and didn't care about infinity focus. There are some medium-format lenses that can be adapted for use on Nikon cameras, though.

Canon has one of the shorter flange to focal-plane distances, so lenses for other mounts can more easily be adapted to Canon EOS (even with the extra spacing of the adapter in place, the lens is still close enough to the sensor/film to focus on infinity).

Adapting Nikon lenses to use on Canon cameras is a pretty common thing to do. For instance, lots of Canon shooters use adapters with Nikon's wide-angle lenses, which are particularly well-regarded.

One note about adapting Nikon lenses for use on Canon bodies. You'll either want to get the older lenses that have a physical aperture ring; or you'll need to get a special "G" adapter that allows you to set the shooting aperture on Nikon's 'G' lenses that have no physical aperture ring. Also, there's no adapter I know of that will work with Nikon's new PC-E lenses, since they have a completely different aperture control mechanism (currently only the three tilt/shift lenses are PC-E, though).

Another consideration is that adapted lenses are going to be completely manual-focus, and you may also lose in-camera metering (best you can hope for is probably spot- or center-weighted metering in manual exposure mode, maybe aperture mode if you're really lucky). So unless you have a specific reason for wanting to use a specific lens, it's probably not worth the trouble. I wouldn't recommend getting an adapter just so you can share lenses with friends. If all your friends shoot Canon and you want to be able to share lenses, you should go with a Canon DSLR.

Originally by user291. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user291

16y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

In general, no—Canon and Nikon DSLR lenses are not directly interchangeable.

They use different mounts, so you would need an adapter. Even with an adapter, results depend on the direction:

  • Canon lens on Nikon body: usually not practical for normal use. Nikon’s longer flange distance means the lens sits too far from the sensor, so you typically lose infinity focus unless optical correction is added. Optical adapters can reduce image quality.
  • Nikon lens on Canon body: more feasible, because Canon EOS bodies have a shorter flange distance. Simple adapters exist, and this is commonly done, but compatibility and convenience are still limited compared with native lenses.

So for everyday shooting, it’s best to use lenses made for your camera’s mount. If lens sharing with friends matters, that can be a real reason to choose the same system they use.

Also, third-party makers such as Sigma and Tamron often offer similar lenses in both Canon and Nikon mounts, which can reduce the impact of choosing one brand over the other.

UniqueBot

AI

16y ago

Your Answer