Which Arca-Swiss Z1 quick release works best with mixed Arca-style plates and L-brackets?

Asked 11/28/2016

7 views

2 answers

0

I’m considering the Arca-Swiss Z1 SP and I’m confused by the quick-release options: MonoballFix, FlipLock, and Classic. I want a clamp that will work with a wide range of Arca-Swiss-style plates and L-brackets, especially Kirk and Wimberley. My understanding is that MonoballFix uses its own plate system. Which option is the best fit if I want broad compatibility?

I’ve also seen a note saying Wimberley safety-stop screws do not work with the newer “double decker” Arca-Swiss clamps on the Z1, even though the plates can still be used. Does that affect which clamp style I should choose?

As a side question, is there any meaningful difference with the Z1+ worth waiting for?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

9y ago

2 Answers

3

The three QR's are Classic knob, Fliplock and monobalfix type. The Fliplock is a quick and sturdy QR. But it is designed for our plates or a single manufacturer's plates only. many of the other manufacturers, while making 'Arca-Swiss style' Qr's and plates, did not copy the specifications and so some are wider and a few are even narrower than our plates. So if you buy a mixture of manufacturers plates, you do not want the fliplock. The Classic QR will accept almost all of the Arca-Swiss style plates made and also will accept the new compact series of monobalfix plates in a dual channel design. The knob is captive so won't unscrew and is extremely rugged and sturdy. The Fliplock will also accept the compact monobalfix plates as well. The monobalfix system will accept only the monbalfix plates and is very compact and makes the head a bit lighter as well. These plates are very compact, as is the QR and rigid as well. Totally centered the compact plates will also pan perfectly if pano stitching is in your bag of tricks. We make L brackets and pano kits for both series of QRs as well. Hope this helps. Rod Klukas Arca-Swiss USA Representative

Originally by user58742. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user58742

9y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

If you want the broadest compatibility with mixed Arca-Swiss-style plates and L-brackets, choose the Classic screw-knob clamp.

Based on the answers:

  • MonoballFix is a proprietary system and only accepts MonoballFix plates.
  • FlipLock is fast and sturdy, but works best when you stick to one plate maker, because “Arca-Swiss style” dimensions vary slightly across brands.
  • Classic accepts almost all Arca-Swiss-style plates and is the safest choice if you want to use Kirk, Wimberley, and other brands interchangeably.

About the Wimberley note: it means the safety-stop screws on some Wimberley plates may not engage with the newer Arca-Swiss clamp design, so the plate can still be used, but you must tighten the clamp securely and not rely on the stop screws alone.

So for your needs, Classic is the most suitable option. FlipLock is better only if all your plates are from the same brand and match its dimensions consistently.

There’s not enough information in the provided answers to say whether the Z1+ is meaningfully different or worth waiting for.

UniqueBot

AI

9y ago

Your Answer