Are RRS lever clamps compatible with all Arca-Swiss plates, or is a screw clamp safer?
Asked 10/10/2012
6 views
2 answers
0
I’m upgrading to a full-size ball head and am considering a Really Right Stuff BH-55 for use on my Manfrotto 055XB legs. I also want to add a nodal slide for panoramic stitching.
My main question is about Arca-Swiss clamp compatibility. I’m choosing between an RRS lever-release clamp and a screw-knob clamp. I’ve read that lever clamps work best when you use one brand of Arca-style plates, while screw clamps are more forgiving across different manufacturers.
If I may mix plates or accessories from brands like RRS, Arca-Swiss, Kirk, or Acratech, is the screw clamp the better choice?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
13y ago
2 Answers
3
I used an RRS lever clamp for a short while long ago (shortly after the lever design came out, if memory serves). (We needed a new support system at work for some product photography and I convinced them to get this gear.) I had heard that only certain plates were compatible, so gave it a shot. Of course, the RRS plates fit just fine. I have an old Arca-Swiss brand "universal" plate that fit just fine, too. I also had an old Kirk plate -- which had seen lots of use and some of the anodized black was wearing off -- and that plate fit differently. It didn't clamp quite as tightly, however it seemed a perfectly fine tight to me. There was no movement to it, but when pushing the lever to clamp, it closed just a little easier.
FWIW, I have an AS B1 (screw-type clamp) and I always thought I wanted a lever clamp because it would be faster and easier to use. I didn't dislike the screw system, and it really is fast to use by sliding the plate in through the side and turning screw knob about a half turn. I was wrong, in that I didn't find the lever to be any faster or easier to use, and since the screw knob doesn't leave me with the fear that I may accidentally pull the lever, it's the system I prefer.
Originally by user8473. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user8473
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes—if you expect to mix Arca-Swiss-style plates from different brands, a screw-knob clamp is the safer choice.
The key issue is that “Arca-Swiss compatible” is not perfectly standardized. Plate widths and tolerances can vary between manufacturers, and even small differences can affect how a lever clamp fits. Community experience here suggests RRS lever clamps work well with RRS plates and can work with some Arca-Swiss and Kirk plates, but the fit may vary.
A screw clamp is infinitely adjustable, so it’s generally the most tolerant option for mixed-brand plates and accessories. That makes it the better all-around choice if you may use plates, rails, or nodal slides from multiple makers.
If you plan to stay entirely within one system, a lever clamp can be fast and convenient. But for maximum compatibility and fewer surprises, the screw clamp is the more flexible answer.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Are Manfrotto Q6 quick-release plates compatible with Acratech and other Arca-Swiss clamps?
Is the Arca-Swiss Z1 clamp compatible with Kirk L-brackets?
Manfrotto RC2/QR2 vs Arca-Swiss quick release: speed or security?
Where can I find an Arca-Swiss compatible quick-release lever clamp?
Which Arca-Swiss Z1 quick release works best with mixed Arca-style plates and L-brackets?