What would translucent aperture blades do to image quality and bokeh?
Asked 1/2/2019
2 views
2 answers
0
Apodization (STF) lenses use a graduated neutral-density element to reduce light from the outer parts of the lens, which is known for smoother bokeh but also lower light transmission. What would happen if a lens instead had translucent aperture blades that still formed the aperture shape but let some light through? Would that give any apodization-like benefit, and how might it affect sharpness, depth of field, exposure control, and bokeh?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
7y ago
2 Answers
1
An apodization filter improves bokeh and sharpness by blocking some of the light coming from the periphery of the objective lens which are prone to greater lens errors. This is effectively the same as how stopping down can improve sharpness and bokeh characteristics.
Translucent aperture blades would be the opposite effect, and they would restrict your ability to control exposure.
Originally by user70370. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user70370
7y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Translucent aperture blades would not behave like a true apodization filter in the useful sense. Apodization works by progressively reducing light from the outer zones of the lens, which also tend to contribute more aberrations; that can smooth bokeh and sometimes improve apparent sharpness, but it costs light transmission.
If the aperture blades themselves were translucent, light would still pass through the area you intended to block. That means the lens would act less like a stopped-down lens and more like a partially blocked wide aperture. In practice, this would reduce your ability to control exposure cleanly and would not give the same sharpness/depth-of-field benefit as a normal smaller aperture.
The closer real-world design is an STF/apodization lens, such as Sony/Minolta STF models, which use a circular graduated ND element rather than translucent blades. Those are specifically designed to improve bokeh smoothness while accepting lower transmission, which is why they may be rated in T-stops as well as f-stops.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI7y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can you use a screw-on apodization filter, or does it need to be inside the lens?
What does an apodization filter do for bokeh, and is it worth it?
Why does a Rosco CT orange + ND filter show 33% transmission for a 1-stop loss?
Why do aperture blades create sunstar rays, and why do odd blade counts produce twice as many?
Why does my Hasselblad Zeiss Distagon 50mm have only a 5-blade aperture?