What does an apodization filter do for bokeh, and is it worth it?
Asked 9/10/2014
3 views
2 answers
0
Fujifilm’s XF 56mm f/1.2 APD includes an apodization element that is described as improving bokeh. Is this essentially a built-in radial neutral-density filter that gets darker toward the edges of the aperture to reduce bright-edged blur discs, or is there more to it? In practical shooting, how noticeable is the effect, and is it always preferable for smoother, more natural-looking background blur? Also, could a similar effect be added with a front screw-on filter, or does the apodization element need to be positioned internally near the aperture?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
11y ago
2 Answers
15
Bokeh is formed by many points of light spreading out, passing through the aperture and being projected onto the image plane as series of overlapping discs (assuming a round aperture).
This can lead to harsh textures and effects when there are strong contrasts in the out of focus parts of an image, especially when lenses feature overcorrected spherical aberration (required for sharp rendering at the plane of focus) as this can cause bokeh discs to be brighter at the edge than in the centre. An apodisation element can reverse the effects of SA overcorrection.
An apodisation element is simply a radial neutral density filter (that gets darker towards the edges) placed near the aperture stop. This causes each disc of light to fade out gradually toward the edges. This helps the individual discs blend together to produce much smoother bokeh. The blur you get is effectively the same as running a Gaussian blur over the image.
It would be possible to get a similar effect using a screw in filter on the front of the lens (just like you can get creative bokeh shapes) but it's better done at the aperture stop as this wont increase vignetting.
An alternative for long exposures with lenses that feature a clickless aperture ring is to gradually stop down the lens during the exposure to create bokeh discs which are exposed less at the edges (and therefor darker).
One downside is that light is lost in the process so lenses with such elements often transmit 1 or 2 stops less light than the f-stop suggests.
Opinion is divided on the value of such an approach with some feeling the resulting bokeh is too smooth and looks fake (due to the similarity with Gaussian blur, which is sometimes used to fake bokeh in photoshop (before the more realistic lens blur filter became available)).
Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1375
11y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
An apodization element is basically a radial neutral-density filter placed near the aperture stop. It transmits more light in the center and less toward the edges, so out-of-focus blur discs fade toward their edges instead of forming bright rims. This can make bokeh look smoother, especially in high-contrast backgrounds and in lenses whose spherical aberration correction would otherwise produce harsh-edged discs.
So yes: the core idea really is “darker toward the edges,” but its placement near the aperture is important. A front screw-on filter would not behave the same way, because it would affect the whole image differently rather than shaping the aperture’s blur discs in the intended manner.
In practice, it can be a meaningful effect for portraits and other shallow-depth-of-field work, but it is not universally “better.” It is an aesthetic choice: smoother blur often comes at the cost of light transmission, and some implementations can interfere with phase-detect autofocus, which is why some APD/STF lenses have AF limitations.
It’s also not the only way to get pleasing bokeh. Lens optical design, aperture shape, and aberration correction all affect blur rendering, so good bokeh can be achieved without apodization too.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI11y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can you use a screw-on apodization filter, or does it need to be inside the lens?
Does an apodization/STF lens cause uneven exposure for landscape photos?
What would translucent aperture blades do to image quality and bokeh?
How do you create circular motion blur around a flash-lit subject?
How does the Nikon D800E cancel the anti-aliasing filter effect?