Were any film cameras designed to be very quiet or nearly silent?
Asked 12/15/2013
3 views
2 answers
0
I know modern mirrorless cameras can use electronic shutters to reduce or eliminate shutter noise. In the film era, that obviously wasn’t possible in the same way, so I’m wondering whether any film cameras were sold that were genuinely very quiet or nearly silent in normal use.
I’m especially interested in cameras that were quiet as designed, not with external blimps or sound-dampening accessories. Were there particular film camera types or models known for especially low shutter noise? Bonus if the film advance was quiet too.
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
19
The original cameras didn't use film at all, so there was no noise from any film advance mechanism. Instead they used materials that were inserted in the back of what we now refer to as view cameras while being protected from exposure to light. Each image required changing out the entire back of the camera and replacing it with another glass plate that had photosensitive materials applied to one side of it.
The "shutter" in those early cameras was often the functional equivalent to a modern lens cap. Since the sensitivity of the materials used was so low as to require several minutes to properly expose a bright, sunny scene the level of precision obtained by removing and replacing a cap over the lens was sufficient.
As photo-sensitive materials improved and shorter exposure times were possible the need for a more precise method of beginning and ending the exposure was needed. Mechanical iris shutters in the lenses were activated by a pneumatic bulb that was squeezed by the photographer. As long as the photographer continued to squeeze the bulb, the shutter remained open. When the photographer released the grip on the bulb and it was allowed to fill with air, the shutter closed. These types of shutters made no more noise than the actuation of modern aperture diaphragms. In fact, in many cases the shutter was an iris that also functioned as the aperture diaphragm. The aperture setting selected by the photographer (or the single setting selected by the camera designer) determined exactly how wide the iris was allowed to open when the bulb was squeezed before it was 'stopped' from opening any wider. The Bulb setting on many modern cameras with focal plane shutters is a reminder of the time when photographers opened and closed the shutters on their cameras by squeezing a pneumatic bulb. So is the term Stop when used in reference to photographic exposure values.
After the invention of film, view cameras remained in use for many years. This is especially true regarding medium and large format cameras that could only accommodate a single film negative at a time. Most of Ansel Adams' work was created using such film based view cameras. By that time the shutter mechanisms, which still resided in the lens for view cameras, were mechanically actuated, usually by means of a spring driven release. This was still much quieter than the later two curtain focal plane shutters used in 35mm cameras such as the earliest SLRs and rangefinder cameras.
Most of the noise associated with 35mm SLR cameras is created by the rapid movement of the mirror, not the actuation of the shutter itself. Many film cameras had methods of locking up the mirror prior to the actuation of the shutter so that the noise created by the mirror cycling could be separated from the time when the photograph was exposed. Since rangefinders have no mirror, their shutters are generally very quiet. The vast majority of both SLR and rangefinder cameras used manual film advance that could be as quiet as a few almost inaudible clicks. The photographer also had the choice of whether to advance the film immediately after exposing it or waiting until a more opportune time when what little noise was created would be less of an intrusion.
In summary, for most of the history of photography cameras were fairly quiet. The generation of SLRs with high frame rates and motor drives to advance film were a fairly late development. Before those developments there was not a huge need for cameras quieter than the norm.
Many of today's upper tier DSLRs have various silent modes that either slow down the mirror so that it is less noisy (at the expense of maximum frame rate) or allow the photographer to separate the timing of the mirror movement and re-cocking of the shutter curtains from the actual moment of exposure.
Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user15871
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes—some film cameras were much quieter than others, though not truly silent in the modern electronic-shutter sense.
The quietest mainstream film cameras were generally leaf-shutter rangefinders, because they avoid the loud mirror slap of an SLR and their shutter mechanism is softer. Compared with an SLR, a leaf shutter can sound dramatically quieter.
A notable example is the early black Konica Hexar AF, which had a well-regarded “silent mode.” It became famous for being unusually quiet for a 35mm film camera, and its built-in 35mm f/2 lens and autofocus also made it popular.
If you go far enough back, very early plate/view cameras could also be effectively quiet because exposure was sometimes made simply by removing and replacing a lens cap, and there was no roll-film advance mechanism. But that’s a very different category from later handheld film cameras.
So the practical answer is: no film camera was literally silent in normal modern-camera terms, but some leaf-shutter cameras—and especially the Konica Hexar AF in silent mode—were close enough to be notably suitable for quiet environments.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How can I reduce DSLR shutter noise in quiet settings?
How can I judge how quiet a camera’s shutter is before buying?
Why is long exposure time limited in Silent Mode on the Panasonic GX80/GX85?
How does the Nikon Z9’s electronic-only shutter work, and why was a mechanical shutter no longer needed?
How can I make a Nikon DSLR quieter for live performances and lectures?