How does the Nikon Z9’s electronic-only shutter work, and why was a mechanical shutter no longer needed?

Asked 11/3/2021

5 views

2 answers

0

The Nikon Z9 was one of the first flagship stills cameras to eliminate a mechanical shutter and rely entirely on an electronic shutter. What changed technically compared with earlier cameras, and why wasn’t this practical before? I’m especially interested in the sensor readout and processing improvements that made this possible.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

4y ago

2 Answers

2

There is nothing new in how the Z9's electronic shutter works... it is still the rolling readout/rolling shutter. What is new is how fast it works.

The Nikon Z9 (and Sony α1 and Canon R3) uses a new stacked CMOS design which is the next evolution in BIS (back illuminated sensor) architecture. The stacked design essentially allows for the designation of entire layers for a particular task.

And in the case of the Z9 it allows for extremely fast readout speeds, nearly entirely eliminating the rolling shutter effect (warping/banding) and allowing the shutter to sync with flash up to 1/200. It was/is primarily the inability of the rolling shutter to sync with flash, and banding under artificial lights, that required/requires the mechanical shutter to be retained.

The stacked CMOS design approaches global shutter functionality without the global shutter drawbacks (cost, reduced FPS, etc).

I cannot say if this is the exact construction of the Z9 (or α1/R3) as that hasn't been released AFAIK; but this is one example of stacked CMOS architecture (separating the memory onto it's own layer) as compared to conventional BIS.

enter image description here

Originally by user70370. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user70370

4y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

The Z9’s electronic shutter is not a fundamentally different kind of shutter than earlier electronic shutters: it still uses sensor readout, typically in a rolling fashion rather than exposing the whole frame at once.

What changed is speed. The Z9 uses a very fast stacked CMOS sensor, an evolution of back-illuminated sensor design, where separate layers can handle different tasks more efficiently. That greatly increases readout speed.

Why that matters: older electronic shutters were often too slow, which caused visible rolling-shutter distortion, banding under artificial light, and poor or unusable flash sync. Those limits are why mechanical shutters were retained in pro cameras.

With the Z9-generation stacked sensor and much stronger onboard processing, readout is fast enough that rolling-shutter artifacts are greatly reduced—low enough to compete with or even improve upon some mechanical focal-plane shutters in practice. The faster readout also enables useful flash sync with the electronic shutter.

So the key advances are:

  • much faster sensor readout
  • stacked CMOS sensor architecture
  • more processing power in a battery-powered camera

Those improvements finally made an electronic-only professional camera practical.

UniqueBot

AI

4y ago

Your Answer