On a Canon EOS 700D, is Scene mode Portrait/Landscape the same as using the matching Picture Style in P/Av/Tv/M?
Asked 9/16/2013
4 views
2 answers
0
On a Canon EOS 700D, I can choose Portrait or Landscape in two different ways:
- The mode dial Scene/Basic Zone setting (for example, Portrait or Landscape)
- A Creative Zone exposure mode (P/Av/Tv/M) with the matching Picture Style selected
Canon describes the Scene modes as things like wider apertures for blurred backgrounds plus softer skin tones, while the Picture Styles are described as affecting rendering such as skin tones, contrast, and sharpness.
Are these actually the same under the hood, or does the Basic Zone Scene mode apply different processing and other automatic adjustments beyond simply selecting the matching Picture Style? In particular, is the mode-dial Portrait/Landscape setting just using the default Portrait/Landscape Picture Style, or does it also change things like exposure, white balance, flash behavior, color rendering, and other camera decisions?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
2
The first key to understand here is the difference between "Basic" zone and "Creative" zone. In the case of Basic zone, the camera is expecting that the photographer has little to no knowledge of photography. It takes over almost all features of the camera and adjusts based on the intent of the user (as set by the given mode).
While I don't know exactly what the basic mode does (I never use it), it most likely does things such as locking the aperture full open (to ensure the smallest depth of field and most background blur) and probably applies the Portrait profile since it specifically mentions altering skin tones (which is a processing step). The Basic modes I have seen almost always simply consist of presets that can be achieved using the "Creative modes" so while I can't guarantee it, it sounds accurate based on the little description the manual gives.
"Creative zone" on the other hand, is the "advanced" shooting mode, or as I like to call it, the non-point and shoot mode. This mode assumes that you have at least a basic understanding of photographic principles, such as metering and the exposure triangle and its elements. It allows the photographer to take control of all the features of the camera. There is often still an automatic mode in this zone where the camera will adjust for exposure based on an exposure compensation, but more features of the camera are still enabled to tweak.
In this zone, aperture is at the control of the user, as is the picture style, so a "Portrait mode" isn't possible, however setting the camera to Av (aperture priority) and locking it at wide open and setting the Portrait image processing preset should give similar color tone and depth of field to what the Portrait mode in the Basic zone did. Also note this only applies to taking JPEG images, not RAW shots (though the preview image for the RAW will be affected.) The image presets are simply adjustments for contrast, sharpness and saturation that the image processing follows when creating a JPEG from the raw image data.
Certainly the best bet to prove there aren't other changes is to setup a controlled test, with consistent lighting, consistent subject and a tripod and try both settings and see if there is a noticeable difference, however I highly doubt there will be anything seriously significant.
Originally by user11392. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user11392
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
No—Canon’s Basic Zone scene modes are not just the matching Picture Style applied in P/Av/Tv/M.
Picture Style mainly controls JPEG rendering: contrast, saturation, sharpness, and tone/color bias. In Creative Zone modes, you still control exposure settings and many other camera options.
Basic Zone scene modes do more. They are designed to make broader decisions for the user, such as favoring a wide aperture for Portrait, adjusting other exposure choices automatically, and likely changing additional camera behavior beyond Picture Style.
From the community tests, matching shutter speed, aperture, ISO, and selecting the same Picture Style still did not produce the same result. Differences were especially visible in color rendering (for example, blues in Landscape and reds in Portrait), showing that the Scene modes use different processing or additional automatic adjustments.
So the practical answer is: the mode-dial Portrait/Landscape settings are not equivalent to simply choosing the Portrait/Landscape Picture Style in a Creative mode. If you want predictable control, shoot in a Creative mode—ideally RAW if you plan to process later.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why does my Canon EOS 700D choose a much slower shutter speed with flash in Av than in P mode?
Do Canon Picture Styles affect white balance when shooting RAW?
Which camera brands use Canon-style Av and Tv mode labels?
Why can’t I change aperture in Manual mode on my Canon EOS 5D Mark II?
How does Program mode differ from scene modes like Portrait?