Is the rewind release button essential on a Mamiya 528AL, and what does it mean if it's stuck?

Asked 1/23/2019

6 views

2 answers

0

My Mamiya 528AL worked for one roll, but on the second roll the advance lever became stiff and the frame counter stopped at 18. I wasn’t sure whether the film was still advancing, so I tried to rewind the film. The rewind release button would not press down. I opened the camera in a dark room and found part of the film tangled around the take-up spool. After removing it, the advance lever worked normally again.

Do I need to repair the rewind release button, or can film be rewound without pressing it? Also, does this sound more like a camera fault or possibly incorrect film loading?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

7y ago

2 Answers

1

I recently bought a perfectly working Mamiya 528AL

The rest of your post directly contradicts this. If where you got the camera from declared it as in mint or great condition, you may want to return it if it is, in fact, not perfectly working.

But, before we get there...

The rewind mechanism is essential. It disengages the film advance so that you can get the film off of the take-up spool and back into the can.

If the button were stuck in, you would still be able to cock the shutter, but the film would not advance, and you'd end up with a double exposure (or more).

However, you state:

But the rewind release button was stuck (and still is)

That statement combined with:

half of it was tangled in the take-up spool,

leads me to believe that the film was incorrectly loaded onto the take-up spool or hopped off through a possible really hard or fast crank on the cocking lever.


To conclude...you shouldn't have sticky liquid anywhere inside the film compartment. The rewind button needs to work. The problem in your last roll could have been due to you cranking the lever or something else entirely. You can try again with another roll and make sure to be easy on the lever to see if this problem occurs again. Though, not having the rewind button means you'll be exiting your film in a darkroom/change bag from here on out until it's fixed.

I recently had two cameras serviced (shutter times adjusted, full cleaning) for roughly ~$250 apiece. I'd expect to pay around that for someone to clean up your camera. This cost is obviously a lot more than the camera's value, so I don't know that I'd actually pay it. You'd be better served returning it and buying from a different seller. (Your camera isn't worth much, but the repairman's time is)

Originally by user67377. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user67377

7y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes, the rewind release button is essential. Its job is to disengage the film advance so the film can come off the take-up spool and rewind back into the cassette. Without it, normal rewinding is not possible.

Based on the symptoms, the jam may have been caused by the film being loaded incorrectly, especially since the film was found tangled on the take-up spool. That can make the advance feel stiff and stop the frame counter.

If the rewind button were stuck in the released position, the shutter could still cock but the film would not advance properly, leading to overlapping exposures. Since your issue was different, improper loading is a likely cause, but a stuck rewind release still means the camera is not fully working as it should.

So: yes, it should be repaired if it truly cannot be pressed, or the camera should be returned if it was sold as fully working.

UniqueBot

AI

7y ago

Your Answer