Is the iPhone 4S good enough as an everyday-carry camera instead of a compact?
Asked 10/17/2011
3 views
2 answers
0
I want a camera with me all the time, but my DSLR is too bulky to carry everywhere. Older phone cameras I’ve tried had poor image quality and were too slow to launch for quick snapshots. The iPhone 4S adds a better sensor/lens and faster camera access from the lock screen. Is it good enough to replace a separate point-and-shoot as an everyday-carry camera, and what are its main limitations?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
14y ago
2 Answers
26
The iPhone 4s alongside iOS5 makes a very compelling argument against a standard point and shoot camera in addition to a phone.
The backside-illuminated CMOS sensor included in the iPhone 4s(iPhone) is the same sensor found in the Sony Ericsson Xperia Arc and the Xperia Neo. Both of these cameras have faired very well in low-light comparison tests. Recent question about the sensor: What are the advantages or disadvantages of a back illuminated CMOS sensor?
iOS5 has made some major improvements to make the experience with the camera more enjoyable. The lock screen has a new way to access the camera that makes opening it up possible without unlocking the device. Images can now be captured not only by tapping the on screen shutter release, but by using the volume up hardware button. In actual use I found found this to be a huge improvement in certain situations. For example, I was taking shots at a concert venue, and holding the camera above by head with one arm. To hold the phone and use the touchscreen at the same time above my head is very difficult, but to use the hardware volume button as the shutter release was very easy and worked well.
If you search online you will find articles outlining how high of a priority the camera operation and speed was to the Apple development team. They supposedly shaved every millisecond possible off of the cameras start-up time to limit the dreaded "aperture" waiting screen that many of us are familiar with.
The iPhone as a camera does have some downsides, the two biggest being that it lacks any optical zoom, and the flash is nearly useless.
Some examples of photography with the iPhone 4 that I did can be found in this answer: How do I get the best results with a cell phone camera?
Overall, I have found the colors, white balance, and speed of the iPhone 4s and iOS5 camera to be very impressive and overall capable in replacing the need for a pocket point and shoot camera.
Some images straight out of the iPhone 4(not as good as the iPhone4s):

Originally by user4892. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user4892
14y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
For many people, yes—the iPhone 4S is good enough to replace a basic point-and-shoot as an everyday-carry camera. The biggest advantage is that you’ll actually have it with you, and iOS 5 improved usability with quicker lock-screen camera access and hardware-button shutter release.
Image quality is also a step up versus older phones, helped by its backside-illuminated sensor, which generally improves low-light performance compared with earlier phone cameras.
That said, whether it’s “good enough” depends on your expectations. It can work very well for casual snapshots and general daily shooting, but it won’t fully replace a more serious compact camera or a DSLR. Fast action, difficult lighting, and situations where you want more control or consistently higher image quality are still better handled by dedicated cameras.
So: as an always-with-you camera, the iPhone 4S makes a strong case against carrying a standard compact. But if you care a lot about action shooting, low-light reliability, or enthusiast-level image quality, it’s still a compromise rather than a full replacement.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI14y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can I save the original non-HDR photo when shooting HDR on an iPhone?
What’s a practical way to carry multiple lenses and filters day to day or when traveling?
Is a 61cm folded tripod too bulky for city use?
Do I need a case or wrap to protect a Canon S90 in a bag?
Compact wildlife camera bag for a DSLR with 100-400mm lens