I put stop bath before developer when processing Tri-X 400—are the negatives usable?

Asked 11/15/2020

4 views

2 answers

0

I accidentally immersed my Tri-X 400 in stop bath before developing it in Rodinal, then developed for about 13 minutes. Could this mistake ruin the film, or is there a chance the negatives will still be usable?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

5y ago

2 Answers

3

Developers work in an alkaline solution. There are exceptions, but they these are uncommon. The chemical goodies that the developer works on are held in place on the film and/or paper by a binder of gelation. We are talking, salts of silver suspended in a coat of purified gelation called an emulsion.

Photo fluids are chemically dilute. In other words they are mainly water. When photo film and papers are submerged in the developer, the gelation emulsion absorbs the water, and like a dry sponge, it swells significantly. This action opens up the gelatin structure allowing the chemicals of the photo process to enter and percolate about and easily exit. The stop bath is a mild acid solution; in fact, is a solution of acetic acid (vinegar).

Films and papers are submerged in the stop bath after the developing step. This acid solution is quickly absorbed by the gelatin emulsion and, because developing takes place in an acid environment, all developing action ceases. Additionally, photo films and papers are still light sensitive at this stage, they need additional chemical treatment to render them light safe.

The third major chemical step of the process is a bath in a fixer solution. This solution is a solvent for residual light sensitive salts of silver. The fixer quickly purges the emulsion of light sensitive chemicals -- thus the film or paper is rendered permanent.
Next we wash or sometimes neutralize all residual chemicals of the process. These fluids, if not removed or chemically made inactive, will stain the finished image. The fixer is a sulfur based solution. If not removed, the sulfur will attack the developed image and stain it severely.

If you accidently place your film in the stop bath and follow this with a developer solution bath, likely the resulting film will be ruined or at best, the images will be substandard. Additionally, the stop solution will shift the developer solution towards the alkaline. This action will contaminate the developer so it must be discarded.

If you are aware of the mistake, stop bath first, likely you could save the film by washing. I would suggest a prolonged washing in running water for 15 or better 30 minutes. After this vigorous wash, you can proceed by restarting the developing steps from the beginning.

Originally by user44949. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user44949

5y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Probably not ruined. A stop bath is a mild acid, and its main effect before development is usually to temporarily acidify and shrink the gelatin emulsion. Rodinal and most film developers work in an alkaline environment, so once the film goes into the developer, that developer can still soak in and begin working.

What may happen is slower developer activity at first, which can reduce development somewhat and possibly lower contrast or density. But a brief or accidental stop-bath-first step does not usually destroy exposed film by itself.

The only way to know for sure is to dry the film and inspect the negatives. If images are present, they are likely printable or scannable, even if a bit thin. If the negatives are very faint, development may have been partially suppressed, but the stop bath alone would not normally erase the latent image.

In short: the film is likely still usable, though results may be weaker than normal.

UniqueBot

AI

5y ago

Your Answer