How should we specify minimum image quality for a print-focused photo archive?
Asked 12/9/2014
9 views
2 answers
0
We are building an internal image archive for marketing use, and many of the images may be printed. Some staff want to require “300 dpi” for every submitted image, but contributors will be using a mix of smartphones and digital cameras, and many files may show 72 dpi in metadata. Since DPI metadata alone does not determine whether a photo is suitable for print, what should we ask contributors to check instead? What is a practical way to define minimum image requirements for an archive intended for print use?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
11y ago
2 Answers
10
Image resolution/pixel dimensions are the attributes you should probably be looking for.
To find out what numbers you should specify in your requirements, you'll need to decide on the maximum size that you'll want to print an image from the archive, then from that you can derive the minimum resolution that images in the archive should have.
For example, if you decide that the largest you'll want to print an image is the full width of an A4 page:
A4 page width in inches= ~8.27 inches
8.27 inches x 300ppi = 2481 pixels
From these numbers you could set a requirement that images submitted to the archive must have a minimum number of say 2500 pixels across.
However, there are a number of further issues that complicate matters.
Firstly (and most importantly IMO) the number of pixels that an image is made up of isn't necessarily a measure of image quality. As an example, my mobile phone and my old Canon 20D dSLR camera, both produce pictures of near identical dimensions, but the quality of those pixels is worlds apart.
Secondly, I imagine most of your images will be submitted as jpeg's so there is a question of the compression setting used. If the camera in use was set to apply heavy compression to the image before saving that'll reduce the quality of the image, whilst maintaining it's outer pixel dimensions.
This means that although you can set requirements for minimum dimensions, it's possible for images to technically meet those rules, and yet actually be of a quality lower than you need.
Thirdly, calculating the minimum image dimensions as above may be overly optimistic. Suppose you need to crop or rotate the images to fit a certain layout, that may necessitate a larger starting file to still get a good print.
Conclusion
Personally, if I were building an image archive for marketing use, I'd want to source images of as high a quality as possible, so the general guidance I would issue would be to make sure the camera was set to it's highest resolutions and quality settings.
Resolution wise I'd issue a guideline that images should be at least 6 Mega Pixels or have their longest side be at least 2500 pixels. (These are the numbers I'd go with, naturally they are dependant on your specific printing requirements.)
Originally by user34468. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user34468
11y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Use pixel dimensions, not DPI metadata, as your submission requirement. A photo file does not have a fixed physical print size on its own; the important question is how many pixels it contains.
Start by deciding the largest print size you want to support, then calculate the minimum pixels needed at your target print resolution. For example:
- 8 × 10 inches at 300 ppi = 2400 × 3000 pixels
- A4 width (~8.27 inches) at 300 ppi = about 2480 pixels across
So instead of saying “300 dpi required,” say something like: “Images must be at least 2400 × 3000 pixels” or whatever fits your maximum intended print size.
Also remember that pixel count alone is not enough. Sharpness, focus, motion blur, compression artifacts, and exposure all affect whether an image is actually usable. If contributors are not expected to evaluate those technically, you can still make pixel dimensions the minimum submission rule and leave final quality review to marketing or archive staff.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI11y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
What standards exist for storing time and location in digital photos, and can they be authenticated?
What resolution do I need for a 24×36-inch photo on a vinyl banner, and does changing DPI in software help?
What image resolution and shooting approach do I need for a clear 10×8 ft trade-show banner?
Should I set all delivered JPEGs to 300 dpi for printing?
Does changing an image to 300 DPI improve print quality for a book?