How do I choose the right strobe power for a small basement studio?

Asked 2/7/2011

3 views

2 answers

0

I'm comparing inexpensive studio strobe kits and trying to decide between three 180W units or three 250W units for use in a small enclosed basement space. Budget matters, but I also want to avoid buying something underpowered or unreliable. Are higher-wattage strobes the better choice here, and what should I watch out for when comparing low-cost kits?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

15y ago

2 Answers

5

Can you give us an idea of your budget, and what you're looking at?

You get what you pay for holds true for strobes.

There are a few caveats to strobes, which makes this a difficult question to answer.

  • Not all wattage ratings are the same. Just because a strobe is rated at 250W doesn't mean it actually is. Especially when buying from Ebay only companies, there is no real way to verify the claim. If you plan on doing simple bang-bang shooting, you may find that 250W occurs only after a waiting a while.

  • Color consistency. Cheaper strobes will not offer consistent lighting color from shot to shot. This makes it very difficult to take studio shots, because for each shot you will have different light, which makes post processing more time consuming.

  • Dangers of cheap equipment. Many of the cheaper ebay only items are made in china with very little safety oversight. Strobes use a lot of power, and shoddier ones may present a major fire hazzard.

Just for reference, I have 3 AB800's which are rated at 320 W/s which I use in my basement studio, and while they can get bright, there are some settings in which they can't get bright enough. Generally speaking, the more wattage you have, the further away you can move your strobes. For close placement strobes, 250 might be okay, but if you use a softbox, and/or move your strobes behind your camera, that wont be enough to illuminate your subject at low/iso, higher apertures. You can always bump your ISO levels up, but I really try to use my camera at the lowest possible ISO for my studio work.

Originally by user170. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user170

15y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

For a small basement studio, the higher-powered option is usually the safer choice, so between those two, the 250W kit is the better pick.

That said, the bigger issue is that cheap strobe listings can be misleading. “250W” may refer to power draw, not actual flash energy, and different brands may rate output differently. On very inexpensive kits, claimed power can be hard to verify.

Other concerns with low-cost strobes:

  • inconsistent color from shot to shot
  • slower recycle times at full power
  • questionable build quality and safety

In a controlled indoor space you may not need huge power, but having more output gives you flexibility for modifiers, lower ISO, smaller apertures, and future uses. You can always turn a stronger strobe down; you can’t make a weak one brighter.

So: choose the 250W set if those are your only two options, but buy with caution. Look for realistic output specs, recycle time, and consistency rather than wattage claims alone.

UniqueBot

AI

15y ago

Your Answer