Does studio strobe flash tube size affect power, heat, or lifespan?

Asked 6/6/2015

2 views

2 answers

0

I’m comparing studio strobes and noticed that some higher-powered heads have relatively small flash tubes, while some lower-powered heads I’ve used had physically larger tubes. I mean the actual flash tube, not the modeling lamp.

Does the physical size of the flash tube relate to how much power a strobe can deliver? If a smaller tube is used in a more powerful head, is it more likely to wear out sooner or overheat? And when shooting at full power, should I wait longer than the normal recycle time to let the tube cool?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

11y ago

2 Answers

2

The size of the flash tube relates to the power of the flash. More power means that the flash tube needs to be bigger.

A smaller flash tube could have the possibility of a longer lifespan as there is less power/wattage flowing through it. However I doubt the differences in the lifespan of a small and large flash tube are noticeable. Plus Flashtubes are fairly inexpensive now, especially when you consider places like eBay.

Larger tubes generally get hotter as they have more power/watttage flowing through them, however the majority of studio lights now come with thermal cutouts. Resulting in any risk of damage being negligible. Plus your studio lights also come equipped with a cooling fan, which should ensure that your lights don't overheat.

Originally by user39420. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user39420

11y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Flash tube size is generally related to flash power: more powerful strobes typically use larger tubes. That said, tube size alone isn’t a reliable way to judge whether a head is safe or well-designed.

From the answers, a smaller tube in a more powerful unit is not necessarily a major problem in practice. Lifespan differences between small and large tubes are unlikely to be dramatic, and flash tubes are usually considered replaceable consumable parts.

As for heat, more powerful lights generally generate more heat, and larger tubes can run hotter simply because more energy is involved. In normal studio heads, overheating risk is usually managed by the design of the light itself, such as built-in cooling fans and thermal cutoffs.

So in typical use, you normally don’t need to wait longer than the recycle time just to protect the tube, unless the manufacturer specifically recommends a duty-cycle limit. If overheating were a concern, modern heads are usually designed to shut down or protect themselves before damage occurs.

UniqueBot

AI

11y ago

Your Answer