Do different studio strobes and speedlites produce different light quality and color?

Asked 2/8/2013

6 views

2 answers

0

I’ve noticed differences between portable speedlites and studio strobes, and even between different strobe systems. Using similarly sized softboxes, some lights seem warmer, some cooler, and some give a different light/shadow definition. Is flash light from different brands and types essentially the same, or can the flash tube design, power control method, and built-in optics/reflectors change the color and overall quality of the light?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

13y ago

2 Answers

4

Yes - Personal experience has shown me that, in particular "speedlights" (IE on-camera / battery powered flash guns) have very differing characteristics in 2 main ways:

  • light spread and uniformity
  • Colour and wavelength content

I have found that cheap (what i like to call Chinese eBay specials) tend to be inferior in both, as they are designed to a price, and use "a flash tube" as opposed to a specially designed tube filled with a special gas mix. So therefore have varying "histograms" (if you like) in the same way that fluorescent lighting lacks certain wavelengths.

Of course we must not forget that all speedlights / flash guns have BUILT-IN Light modifiers, so the design of the reflectors and fresnel lenses within make a huge difference to the spread and uniformity, especially in the zoom models.

The same can be said for studio flashes, although the light modifiers are usually detachable, so cant really be considered in this case.

DONT FORGET - White Balance CANNOT cure everything if the wavelength was missing in the first place, that "information" cannot be re-created. A prime example being near-monochromatic sodium street lighting - if you try to get rid of the orange cast via white balance, you will end up with a near B&W image.

Originally by user9999. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user9999

13y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes. Different flashes can produce noticeably different color and light characteristics.

From the answers, the main differences are:

  • Color temperature: Some speedlites and certain portable packs can look cooler because they reduce power by cutting the flash off electronically. Many studio strobes lower power by charging the capacitors less and letting the flash decay naturally, which can produce a warmer result.
  • Spectrum/wavelength content: Not all flash tubes are identical. Better-designed tubes and gas mixes can give more consistent color and spectral output.
  • Beam spread and uniformity: Speedlites include built-in reflectors and Fresnel optics, so their native light pattern can differ a lot. Cheaper units may have less even spread.
  • Modifiers matter a lot: A softbox, reflector, grid, etc. strongly shapes the final result, often more than the flash brand alone.

So no, flashes are not all exactly the same. Differences in tube design, electronics, reflector/Fresnel design, and modifier choice can all affect the look. That said, good technique and modifier use matter more than price alone, and excellent results are possible with modest gear.

UniqueBot

AI

13y ago

Your Answer