Does TTL flash automatically overexpose a scene that's already metered correctly?

Asked 5/30/2013

4 views

2 answers

0

I'm learning TTL flash and trying to understand how it works with the camera's normal metering. My assumption was: if the camera has already chosen exposure settings for the ambient light, then adding flash afterward would brighten the scene and therefore overexpose it. Since TTL uses a pre-flash to calculate flash power, does TTL normally account for the existing ambient exposure and add only the amount of flash needed? Or does it depend on the flash mode and camera implementation?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

13y ago

2 Answers

3

Not exactly, but I understand why you would think that. The goal of TTL flash-metering is actually to calculate the correct amount of light to output in order to expose a scene properly.

There are several flash modes which are independent of TTL metering. Which ones are available will depend on your camera. The one you describe is called Fill flash. In this case, the scene is correctly exposed without the flash and the flash is added to fill out shadows and reduce contrast. Therefore the flash output is set to be generally weak compared to the light in the scene. On dark parts, they would become brighter but should not over-expose. On the brightest part of the image, one could conceivably add just enough light to push someone to over-expose but that should be rare given the flash power is weak relative to the brightest parts of a scene.

There are other modes where the scene is exposed less than needed to be properly exposed and then the flash is counted upon to add enough illumination. Results depend on the scene because flash affects things differently based on distance and reflection. Depending on how your camera meters, the resulting exposure can bring one part of the image to look good while another part may overexpose.

Originally by user1620. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1620

13y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

No. TTL flash is not defined to overexpose the subject.

TTL systems use the pre-flash together with the camera’s ambient metering to calculate how much flash is needed for the intended result. In other words, the flash is usually part of the overall exposure calculation, not something blindly added on top afterward.

If the scene is already well exposed by ambient light, TTL may use the flash as fill flash: adding a relatively small amount of light to lift shadows and reduce contrast without blowing highlights. In that case, the exposure can stay essentially correct while the quality and direction of light improve.

That said, TTL is not perfect. It can be fooled by some scenes and may need flash exposure compensation or regular exposure compensation. Also, behavior can vary somewhat by camera mode and brand implementation.

So the key idea is: TTL aims to balance ambient and flash for a proper exposure. It may overexpose in some situations, but not by definition.

UniqueBot

AI

13y ago

Your Answer