Does editing a RAW file in Adobe Camera Raw change the original file?
Asked 5/5/2011
3 views
2 answers
0
I shoot RAW or JPEG+RAW and sometimes open my files in Adobe Camera Raw. If I adjust exposure, white balance, or other settings, does that modify the original RAW file itself, or are the edits stored separately? What is the difference between opening normally and using “Open as Copy,” and can the RAW file’s timestamp or original capture data be changed by these edits?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
15y ago
2 Answers
14
Using Adobe Camera RAW you are essentially just flipping switches that don't do much till you export the file to a format such as JPEG. Your original capture time, and the EXIF data associated with that original shot will not degrade due to you changing the EV value or similar.
Changes made to the RAW file are completely non-destructive. The only thing that changes is the metadata stored on how to render that image to an output such as JPEG. The original file is left unchanged and intact completely.
Technically Adobe Camera RAW as part of Photoshop has the option to store your camera raw settings in two places, either the Camera Raw Database or an XMP Sidecar File. The Camera Raw database is indexed by file content, so the image retains camera raw settings even if the camera raw image file is moved or renamed(on the same computer). The XMP sidecar file stores the settings in a separate file, in the same folder as the camera raw file, with the same base name and an .xmp extension.(ref)
If you edit a RAW file in an Application such as Lightroom, you have the option to store the changes to a sidecar XMP file. This not only preserves the original RAW file without modification, but frees your images from the Lightroom catalog. You can now move your files around and only bring along the XMP file instead of the entire Lightroom catalog.
Overall, go ahead and mess around with the Camera RAW settings, you aren't going to do any damage.
Originally by user4892. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user4892
15y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
With Adobe Camera Raw, RAW edits are generally non-destructive. Adjustments like exposure or white balance do not alter the original sensor data in the RAW file. Instead, the settings are stored as metadata, typically either in an .xmp sidecar file with the same base filename or in Adobe’s database.
That means the original capture data and EXIF from the shot remain intact, and your edits are only instructions for how to render the image when viewing or exporting it to JPEG, TIFF, etc.
In normal use, opening a RAW file directly in Camera Raw does not rewrite the RAW itself. If you want to reset everything, deleting the sidecar file or clearing the saved settings will usually return the image to its original state.
“Open as Copy” is mainly for working on a separate version, but for RAW processing the important point is that your edits are normally stored separately rather than baked into the RAW file.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI15y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Which edits are truly RAW-specific, and how do they differ from Photoshop adjustments?
Does editing EXIF metadata change JPEG image quality?
Does Photoshop’s Camera Raw Filter keep the full RAW data, or should I edit in ACR first?
Should I make RAW adjustments in Adobe Camera Raw or wait and do them in Photoshop?
Does a photo stay "raw" after opening from Adobe Camera Raw into Photoshop?