Do picture styles affect RAW sharpness and contrast, or only JPEG/video?

Asked 1/10/2014

4 views

2 answers

0

On cameras that offer picture styles/presets such as Portrait or Landscape, do settings like sharpness, contrast, and similar adjustments change the actual RAW file, or do they only affect JPEGs and video recorded in-camera?

If they do not affect RAW, is there any benefit to lowering sharpness or contrast in the camera anyway so I have more control later in post-processing?

I have also heard that lowering contrast is useful when shooting video. Is that mainly because most video is not recorded in RAW, unlike still photos?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

0

Presets and picture effects, such as sharpness and contrast, are only applied to the file types that are 'developed' in the camera, such as jpegs and video files, and not to the raw data that can be saved to the memory card. But even though changing jpeg-only effects like Sharpness has no effect on the raw image, you might still have reasons to use them.

The camera will generate a jpeg image based on your image preset settings, and it uses this to show you the image on the LCD as well as provide information for the Histogram and highlight warnings. Boosting your contrast settings, for example, can make the tones that your camera reports too extreme, giving the impression of exposure problems that don't exist in the underlying information.

Once nice side effect of this is being able to use the monochrome camera settings to preview/review an image in black and white right on your camera, without giving up colour and all of the options it provides in the recorded image. And if you like a particular look that can be set in the camera, but don't want to record it as a jpeg, it will also let you see what the potential result can be.

Originally by user24260. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user24260

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Picture styles/presets such as Portrait or Landscape generally do not change the underlying RAW sensor data. They do affect files the camera processes in-camera, especially JPEGs and typically video.

However, those settings can still matter when shooting RAW because the camera usually uses a JPEG preview based on the selected picture style for the rear screen, histogram, and highlight warnings. If you raise contrast or sharpness a lot, the preview may make the image look harsher or more clipped than the RAW data really is. Using a lower-contrast style can therefore give a more conservative, useful preview when exposing RAW stills.

For JPEG shooting, these settings directly affect the final file, so choosing lower sharpness/contrast can leave more room for later editing if that matches your workflow.

For video, the advice to reduce contrast is more important because most video is recorded in a processed format rather than RAW. Lower-contrast settings can help preserve highlight and shadow detail for grading later.

So: RAW files themselves are generally unaffected, but the preview and exposure aids are affected; JPEGs and most video are affected directly.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer